Pay equity case breaks new ground after surprise court ruling

It’s been a long time coming but this discrimination case could see one company forced to reach a settlement with former female employees.

Pay equity case breaks new ground after surprise court ruling
A Federal Court of Appeal decision has seen Nav Canada edge closer to a wage discrimination payout for up to ‘several hundred’ female employees.
 
In a case 15 years in the making, the Federal Court of Appeal has ruled that a Public Service Alliance of Canada (PSCA) complaint originally dismissed by the Canadian Human Rights Commission for being outside its jurisdiction did in fact deserve to be heard, opening the door for progress in the case.
 
The PSAC filed a complaint with the CHRC in 2002 alleging that the Treasury Board and Nav Canada had discriminated against some of their female employees by not awarding them some required pay equity adjustments.
 
However, the CHRC dismissed the PSAC complaint without an investigation in 2012, which was later backed up by a decision in the Federal Court.
 
The recent Federal Court of Appeal ruling reverses these decisions, giving the PSAC another chance to pursue Nav Canada for a pay equity settlement.
 
“It was not reasonable for the commission to conclude that PSAC’s complaint plainly and obviously did not contain reasonable grounds to suggest that wages at NAV are discriminatory,” the Federal Court of Appeal ruling said.
 
Andrew Raven, the PSAC’s lawyer in the case, told the Ottawa Citizen that the decision had “important implications for all pay equity complainants”.
 
“What it means, in our view, is that the commission is going to have to do a proper investigation now,” Raven told the Citizen.
 
The PSAC reached a $3.6bn pay equity deal with the federal government in 1999, which saw some female employees of Transport Canada – classified as CR’s – receive pay equity cheques for the years between 1985 and 1996.
 
However, these women got no wage adjustment for later years working at successor company Nav Canada, though the same problematic categories were used. A gender-neutral classification was not taken up until 2011.
 
Raven estimates the wage cheques for one classification – CR4s – at about $2500 per year, which could apply between the years 1997 and 2011.
 
 

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up-to-date with the world of HR. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from HRD Canada.

Recent articles & video

Fun Friday: 10 annoying habits to kick in 2020

How can HR reengage a 'checked out' team?

Leveraging virtual care for mental health support

Your employees have been publicly accused of discrimination. Now what?

Most Read Articles

Fun Friday: Top 5 employee benefits for 2020

Can employees sue HR over bad references?

Five HR transformation strategies in 2020