Far out Friday: Judge throws out employee’s “tight skirt” injury claim

The airline worker sued for $54K after injuring her back at a check-in desk, insisting her tight uniform was to blame.

Far out Friday: Judge throws out employee’s “tight skirt” injury claim
A former airline worker has had her bizarre injury claim thrown out of court this week after a judge noticed inconsistencies in her story.

County Dublin-based Agnieszka Spyra claimed the uniform she was required to wear while working for Ryanair caused her on-the-job back injury – specifically noting the “high heels and tight skirt.”

The 35-year-old was seeking €38,000 (CA$53,900) from the low-cost carrier and a recruiting firm, insisting she’d been injured while lifting a light bag onto a conveyer belt but the claim was thrown out by Judge Jacqueline Linnane after Spyra gave conflicting statements about the event.

While she had previously told Injuries Board investigators and her doctor that she was seated when she suffered the injury, she told the court that she was standing when she lifted the 8kg case and felt a shooting pain in her lower back.

Spyra was also unable to prove that the budget airline had failed to provide adequate safety training in regards to handling passengers’ luggage.

The judge also ordered Spyra to cover Ryanair and Mk Human Resources’ legal costs but the instruction has been stalled as the former employee considers an appeal.

More like this:

CHROs take centre stage at Toronto summit

Union tactics and hot to overcome them

Should HR go for after-work drinks?
 

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up-to-date with the world of HR. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from HRD Canada.

Recent articles & video

What's the key to achieving workplace happiness?

This type of employee struggles to befriend their colleagues

Will 'virtual' mental health care save your staff?

HR on set? TV network revamps HR policy

Most Read Articles

How does harassment impact workplace culture?

Should HR encourage exercise at work?

Supreme Court rules independent contractor was an employee