HR leaders must treat immigration as strategy, not paperwork: HRFest Canada panel

Canada’s immigration reset is a signal for HR leaders to build workforce plans around global talent, not scramble for permits

HR leaders must treat immigration as strategy, not paperwork: HRFest Canada panel

Canada’s HR leaders can no longer treat immigration as a process that starts after a hiring decision has been made. With baby boomer exits at their peak, non-permanent resident numbers declining sharply, and a widening skilled trades gap, immigration has become a strategic imperative – not a downstream administrative task.

That was the central message from the panel “Immigration and Global Talent: From Policy Shock to Strategic Advantage” at the HRFest Canada 2026 HR Leaders Forum, featuring Pedro Antunes, chief economist at Signal49 Research in Ottawa and Cosmina Morariu, managing partner of Fragomen Canada in Toronto – the largest global immigration law firm, operating in more than 170 jurisdictions.

A labour market under strain

The economic backdrop is sobering, with Canada’s employment been essentially flat for a year and job creation at a standstill, according to Antunes.

“our expectation is that job gains are going to be very slow going forward, even as the economy hopefully picks up a little bit next year,” said Antunes.

Compounding that stagnation is a demographic wave at its peak: approximately 300,000 baby boomers are exiting the workforce this year alone – StatCan’s Retirement and post-retirement employment among older Canadians report pegged the exact number of retirements at 276,800 in August 2025 – in a country of 41 million, while at the same time, the federal government reversed course on its non-permanent resident intake, said Antunes. Non-permanent residents – including temporary foreign workers, international students, and refugees – peaked at 7.6 per cent of Canada’s population on Oct. 1, 2024 and had dropped to 6.8 per cent one year later, according to Statistics Canada. The government’s target of reducing that peak share to five per cent amounts to an exodus of roughly 950,000 people, he said.

“We’re exiting a million people in a blink of an eye,” Antunes said. “Our population is 10 times less [than the U.S.], but essentially they’re exiting a million people over a couple of years – it’s huge what we’re doing here in this country.”

The latest federal budget offers some relief, allowing 200,000 non-permanent residents to transition into permanent status through provincial nominee programs, with 115,000 eligible protected persons and 33,000 work permit holders already set up to accelerate their permanent residency in the 2025 federal budget. The challenge of sourcing sufficient talent – explored in HRD Canada’s coverage of why global mobility can no longer wait – has never been more urgent.

A global talent system out of step with what employers need

Antunes identified a persistent structural flaw: Canada’s immigration point system is weighted toward university-educated newcomers, even as the economy increasingly needs skilled tradespeople. He pointed out that the federal government’s Spring 2026 economic update projects a need for 1.4 million skilled trades workers by 2033 and commits $6 billion toward training 100,000 of them – a substantial shortfall.

The labour market has also shifted in ways that upend longstanding assumptions. For the first time, the unemployment rate for Canadians with a university degree now exceeds that of those without one, Antunes said, adding that AI adoption is accelerating this disruption: AI could add as much as five per cent to Canada’s national productivity over time, which, compounded annually, could flatten job creation even as the economy grows.

“We've had a permanent resident stream which is focused on… highly educated, highly skilled workers coming in, but then there's a huge credentialing issue when they arrive – that's been a longstanding issue in Canada,” said Antunes. “We need to be less biased about getting an education such as a university degree, versus getting skilled trades.”

Morariu agreed in the need for a shift in how international talent is brought to Canada. “We as a country are competing for talent with other countries… so that's where we need to be more agile when it comes to change,” she said.

The misalignment between how Canada selects immigrants and what employers actually need has drawn independent scrutiny, as HRD Canada’s reporting on Canada’s immigration system needing a reset has examined.

Mobility HR: from permit process to strategic function

HR’s immigration function now requires significant transformation, said Morariu. “HR and mobility is no longer about recruitment,” she said. “It’s more than that. It’s about business resilience – looking at adding mobility HR to workforce planning and succession skills, whether it's upskilling, reskilling, or looking at geopolitical risk.”

The question HR leaders are now expected to answer is no longer whether a permit is needed for a specific candidate – it is whether the organization has the talent pipeline to sustain growth, the workforce intelligence data to track authorizations and expiry dates in real time, and the crisis management capacity to respond to geopolitical disruption, according to Morariu.

“HR and mobility used to come after business decision was made – it was dessert at the end of the process,” she said. “Now it’s actually the appetizers. We need to be ready with the data for business decision to be made.”

Morariu also pointed to a talent pool many organizations are leaving untapped: individuals displaced by conflict or inequality, including engineers and legal professionals. She urged employers to move past the negative connotations sometimes attached to temporary workers and assess displaced candidates as they would any other hire. As HRD Canada’s examination of how global mobility risk can no longer be an HR afterthought makes clear, organizations building that capability now are those that will adapt fastest.

What CHROs should prioritize now

Morariu outlined four priorities for senior HR leaders: build real-time workforce intelligence data so the organization always knows where employees are and whether work authorizations are current; construct an immigration risk map; require a business case for every international assignment; and plan talent movement in advance to allow room for adaptability if things change. She also flagged a compliance exposure some employers may be underestimating: Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) has introduced administrative monetary penalties for providing or facilitating paid immigration advice without proper authorization, with penalties reaching up to $1.5 million in serious cases.

Antunes urged employers to advocate. “Immigration is a way to supplement those gaps in the workforce that we can’t meet elsewhere,” he said. “But I know it is difficult [when] employers aren’t directly able to affect some of these policies.”

LATEST NEWS