A sales rep's own corporation couldn't hide his real employment status
A roofing salesperson had his paycheque routed through his own company for years. An Ontario court still ruled him an employee, but that finding didn't get him anywhere close to the payday he wanted.
In a decision released Sept. 14, 2026, Justice Paul Schabas of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice ruled that a sales rep for Guycan Ltd., a roofing company, was an employee rather than a contractor, even though his pay flowed through his own personal corporation. Schabas also found the worker had quit rather than being pushed out of the job, a finding that closed off his claim for termination pay and left him with a fraction of the roughly $500,000 he had been chasing.
Getting paid through a corporation didn't make him a contractor
The worker joined the roofing company in December 2017 to land new contracts as an account executive. Both sides signed what the company itself labelled an "Employment Agreement," setting a weekly salary, statutory holiday pay, vacation time, and unpaid sick days.
At his own request, his pay flowed through his personal corporation instead of coming to him directly, giving him tax perks like writing off expenses. No statutory deductions came off those payments, and his corporation, not the roofing company, covered his workplace insurance. None of that, Schabas found, changed what the relationship actually was.
He drew a regular salary, was trained and supervised by the owners, worked full-time, and had no say over pricing or suppliers, with no financial risk if a job lost money. In the court's view, he was carrying on the company's business, not his own, and was an employee from December 2017 to summer 2020.
A two-week notice that stuck
Frustrated by delays in getting paid and cuts to his incentive bonus, the worker first tried to resign in late 2019, but stayed after the company agreed he would not have to split certain commissions. The truce did not last. On July 16, 2020, he texted the company's owner giving two weeks' notice, saying the job no longer suited him.
Reluctant to lose him, the owner offered him a new sales opportunity during his notice period, which he turned down, and the two sides spent weeks trying to hammer out a new agreement. Talks fell apart in mid-August after the company rejected some changes. In an email, he said the company's stance was the main reason it was no longer the place for him.
Schabas ruled that this added up to a clear resignation, not a constructive dismissal (legal shorthand for being pushed out): "A resignation must be clear and unequivocal." The company, he found, never fired him or changed his job unilaterally, and in fact tried hard to keep him. He wasn't entitled to notice pay or dismissal damages.
How past practice settled an ambiguous pay clause
The biggest fight was over how his commission and incentive bonus should have been calculated. His contract set a five per cent commission on a project's "gross hard cost" and a 50 per cent share of any "overage," but neither term was defined. According to his submissions, the figures should reflect actual project costs and profits, not estimates from an internal pricing tool, a claim his expert valued at more than $500,000.
That tool, an internal spreadsheet used to quote every job, built in the same commission structure the contract referenced, Schabas found. He read the agreement by giving "the words used their ordinary and grammatical meaning," weighed against what both sides knew at signing. He also noted that for two and a half years, the worker invoiced commissions using the spreadsheet's own figures without ever challenging the method.
Having rejected that reading, Schabas ordered smaller amounts: underpaid commissions on 12 completed projects, commissions on seven unbilled projects, four extra days of base pay, and public holiday pay owed since March 2018, plus vacation pay on top. The company's counterclaim was tossed out entirely.