Board rejects complaint about water-monitoring consultant, declines to award damages
A recent case before the B.C. Supreme Court shows how quickly one strike can become a multi-front legal fight for Canadian HR leaders and employers.
A judge is expected to rule this week on whether to bar picketing linked to the strike at Teck Resources’ Highland Valley Copper mine. The ruling comes days after British Columbia’s Labour Relations Board (BCLRB) found Teck breached the province’s Labour Relations Code “by using ineligible replacement workers to perform bargaining unit work,” as CBC News reported from the decision.
Port operator PKM Canada Services Inc. sought the injunction at a hearing on Monday, Courthouse News Service reported.
What the labour board found
The decision, 2026 BCLRB 349, dated Nov. 13, 2026, was issued by board vice-chair Paul Todd and ordered Teck to stop the practice, according to the BC Labour Relations Board’s online decisions registry.
Two breaches involved bargaining unit members promoted to supervisor shortly after bargaining began on June 9, 2026, according to CFJC Today. A third involved a rehired retiree, which Teck conceded. The fourth involved a contractor clearing snow from a mine road.
The board rejected a complaint about a water-monitoring consultant and declined to award damages, noting such remedies are rare for a first violation, CBC News reported.
Dispute with wider stakes
More than 1,200 members of United Steelworkers (USW) Local 7619 walked out on Oct. 24, 2026, and Teck says the mine is operating at reduced capacity, according to Castanet Kamloops. Kyle Wolff, the local’s president in Logan Lake, B.C., has said Teck is seeking a 25% cut to future pension contributions, calling it a “punitive hit.”
Teck has maintained it complies with provincial labour law and remains committed to a fair negotiated agreement, Castanet Kamloops reported.
The dispute has also reached the waterfront. The BC Federation of Labour (BCFED) urged unions not to handle the mine’s concentrate, prompting PKM’s injunction bid, according to Investing News Network and Courthouse News Service.
Why it matters to employers across Canada
Labour conflict is widespread. Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC) recorded 219 work stoppages in 2025, involving 288,235 workers and about 4.26 million person-days not worked, according to its preliminary federal work stoppage data by jurisdiction and year.
The room to operate during strikes is narrowing. Quebec and B.C. restrict replacement workers, and Bill C-58 has barred federally regulated employers from using them since June 20, 2025, with fines of up to $100,000 a day, according to law firm Borden Ladner Gervais LLP. HRD Canada has outlined how HR can prepare for Bill C-58 and its restrictions, following the federal government’s original move to ban scab workers.
The Teck ruling shows where risk sits: promotions after bargaining begins, rehires during a dispute and contractor work scopes all deserve legal review before a strike deadline. And with Ottawa now seeking new powers to end disputes, as HRD Canada explored in its analysis of whether Bill C-39 strike curbs will stop work disruptions, the rules governing strikes are shifting fast – making early labour relations planning a core HR responsibility.