Police were called, a vote got blocked, and the judge wasn't having it
A Vancouver restaurant's owners tried to freeze out their day-to-day partner, called the police to have him removed, and then blocked him from voting on his own dismissal. A judge ruled that was oppressive and ordered the business to pay him damages.
The ruling came down Oct. 2, 2026, from Justice Branch of the Supreme Court of British Columbia, who found that the consulting firm behind the restaurant, the numbered company that ran it, and that company's other director had treated the restaurant's general manager and 49 per cent shareholder unfairly. The judge ordered a $40,000 payment to him: $5,000 for lost pay, $15,000 in aggravated damages and $20,000 in punitive damages, to come out of the restaurant's sale proceeds, which are sitting in trust.
A restaurant built on sweat equity
The story starts with a restaurant on Commercial Drive that a consulting firm and a former restaurant manager decided to build together back in 2021. Their deal: the firm put up $250,000 for 51 per cent of the business, and the manager took the other 49 per cent, a $60,000 salary and day-to-day control of the place, in exchange for the work of actually running it.
Construction blew past budget, and by mid-2022 the restaurant needed more cash. So the partners reworked the deal: the manager gave up a monthly fee for a bump in salary to $90,000, and both sides agreed to lend the business more money, including $40,000 from the manager himself. The owners later claimed they had no idea where that $40,000 came from. The judge didn't buy it. Correspondence between the parties showed the money had come from restaurant suppliers eager to get their products on the menu, and that the owners knew it at the time.
The restaurant itself, a Spanish spot called Osita with live music, opened in June 2022. It lost money early on, which the manager had warned the owners to expect going in. By April 2023, though, that warning had worn thin, and the owners were getting nervous about the books.
The campaign to stop the bleed
That nervousness turned into action while the manager was away on vacation. The owners told several of the restaurant's own managers that the business was failing and that they planned to stop paying him. The same day, in an email to him, they put it bluntly: "WE MUST STOP THE BLEED NOW." The manager wrote back with a detailed response and asked for a mediator. Nobody replied.
On July 5, 2023, with no board meeting and no vote, one of the owners handed him a letter firing him, with two weeks' pay in lieu of notice. Told to leave immediately, he was on the phone with his lawyer when the owners called the police to remove him; he left rather than make a scene. Nine days later, that same owner blocked him from voting at the board meeting that ratified his own removal, citing a conflict of interest.
Once he was out, the owners ran the place themselves, brought in a new manager, dropped the live music, and turned the Spanish-themed Osita into an Italian restaurant called Vivace on the Drive, despite a clause requiring everyone's sign-off on changes that big. Separately, the consulting firm had accused the manager of trying to make off with the restaurant's liquor licence, a claim that quietly disappeared partway through the hearing once records showed he had kept the owners in the loop the whole time.
What it cost to push him out
Justice Branch found that all of this added up to what the law calls oppression, conduct that violates a shareholder's reasonable expectations. Those expectations, in this case, were spelled out in a roles-and-responsibilities agreement the partners had signed. Undermining the manager's authority, firing him without a board process, ignoring his requests to mediate, and overhauling the restaurant's concept without approval might each look minor alone, but together, the judge found, they crossed a line.
Because his job was so tied up with his shares in the business, the judge ruled he could collect damages similar to a wrongful-dismissal payout, even though a separate wrongful dismissal lawsuit he filed is still working its way through a different court. That payout totaled $40,000: $5,000 for a month's lost pay, $15,000 in aggravated damages and $20,000 in punitive damages. On the aggravated-damages piece, Justice Branch wrote that "the abrupt rupture from his passion project" justified the award.
The punitive damages reflected a finding that the manager's exclusion was deliberate and done in bad faith, made worse by a liquor-licence allegation the firm didn't drop until partway through the hearing, long after the paper trail showed it had nothing behind it. The court also threw out the firm's own complaints about the manager, including claims that he limited the owners' access to financial records, padded invoices for marketing work billed by his wife, and tried to quietly restore his own salary after agreeing to a cut. None of it held up, and the judge refused to let the firm sue him further.
See Woldring & Co. Consulting Inc. v Sugarman, 2026 BCSC 1888