Are you falling for the 'loyalty illusion'?

New report shows employees are staying, but not really committing to their employer

Are you falling for the 'loyalty illusion'?

Employees who stay in their current job are not necessarily committed to the organisation, according to a new report, which has put the spotlight on a "loyalty illusion" that employers need to be aware of.

This loyalty illusion refers to a situation that's affecting one in five employees in a new Wiley survey. They are employees who expect to stay in their current job but aren't necessarily committed to the organisation itself.

"They're still showing up, meeting expectations, and contributing. But there's a difference between retaining employees and earning their loyalty," the Wiley report read.

According to the report, 82% of employees said they are likely to be with their current employer 12 months from now.

But among them, one in four couldn't confidently say they would still stay if the job market were ideal and there were plenty of opportunities available.

"The loyalty illusion isn't about making it harder for employees to leave. It's about giving them a reason to choose to stay, even when the job market inevitably changes," the report read.

What's making employees stay?

The respondents cited a variety of reasons for staying with their current employer, including enjoying their work (58%) and their team (43%).

"That's important because teams are something leaders can actually influence. Colleagues provide belonging, support, and a shared sense of purpose," the report read.

"Those relationships create a strong foundation for building loyalty and addressing the loyalty illusion. Building better colleague relationships is possible through personality assessments and learning experiences that boost interpersonal skills and understanding."

What's hurting commitment?

However, the report underscored that teams can only do so much when it comes to retention, stressing that employees will start questioning their place in an organisation if their learning curve and career have flattened.

The report also noted that employees will be more inclined to leave if their current position does not utilise all of their strengths.

But employers may not be aware of these feelings, as only 62% of employees said they can express career concerns without worrying that these will be held against them.

"If they don't feel comfortable raising those questions, their manager may see a successful employee while that employee quietly wonders what else is out there," the report warned.

How to boost loyalty at work

The report advised organisations to start investing in the team experience if they want to convert employees' decisions to stay into long-term commitment.

"Create opportunities for collaboration, build trust, and reinforce a shared sense of purpose. The people employees work alongside can make a meaningful difference in whether they want to stay," the report read.

More importantly, it urged employers to foster space for honest conversations to make speaking up easier. This includes checking in early and often, rather than waiting for annual performance reviews to talk about career goals.

It is also important that employers give employees the opportunity to use their strengths at work.

"Use development tools to help employees and managers understand how people work best and where they have room to grow. Give managers the insight they need to make more intentional decisions about responsibilities, development opportunities, and role fit," the report read.

LATEST NEWS