A wage bump wasn't enough to make this new contract stick
A forest products company's attempt to cap a longtime employee's severance backfired when a British Columbia court found the new contract that created the limit was never properly earned in the first place.
In a decision released Sept. 17, 2026, Justice Wilson of the Supreme Court of British Columbia ruled that a moulder technician's 2024 employment contract with Ivor Forest Products Ltd. was unenforceable, entitling him to six months' pay in lieu of notice under common law rather than the reduced statutory minimum the company had sought to apply.
A raise arrives with a new contract
The employee, a moulder technician, had worked for the Chilliwack-based company since January 2021 under an initial employment offer that placed no limits on his entitlements if he were let go without cause. In November 2024, nearly four years into the job, he signed a new contract that came with a wage increase to $38.50 an hour from $35.
The new agreement also included a clause capping his termination entitlements at the statutory minimum under the Employment Standards Act, plus one extra week of pay. That clause became central once the employee was dismissed without cause in October 2025.
For the reduced payout to apply, the company needed to show the employee received something new and valuable in exchange for accepting the tighter terms, a legal requirement known as fresh consideration. Without it, courts treat contract changes introduced partway through employment as unenforceable.
The consideration that wasn't
The company argued that three things justified the new contract: the wage increase, a new RRSP matching program, and eligibility for a performance bonus. Justice Wilson rejected all three as consideration for the deal.
The RRSP matching commitment had already been made before the new contract was offered, the court found, and the bonus program was never mentioned in the document the employee signed, which stated it replaced all previous agreements. As for the wage increase, the employee's original offer already entitled him to an annual wage review, one the company had failed to conduct for three straight years.
Justice Wilson concluded the employer could not point to anything the employee received beyond what he was already owed, finding that “the defendant has not established that the 2024 Contract is supported by any fresh consideration.” As a result, the original, unrestricted offer of employment remained in force.
Six months, no extra damages
With the contract limit set aside, the court turned to how much notice the employee was owed under common law. At 48 years old with nearly five years of service in a specialized but non-managerial role, he said eight months was appropriate; the company maintained three to five months was enough.
Drawing comparisons to other non-managerial employees of similar age and length of service, Justice Wilson found that “the plaintiff was entitled to six months pay in lieu of notice.” The court also declined to reduce that amount despite the employee not beginning his job search until roughly six months after his termination, ruling the employer had not proven suitable work was actually available to him.
The employee also alleged the company acted in bad faith during his dismissal, pointing to a disputed written warning, the timing of his termination after he raised payroll concerns, and delays in his final pay and record of employment. Justice Wilson dismissed the claim for aggravated damages, finding no evidence of distress beyond the ordinary upset that comes with losing a job.