'Get out or I'll call police': law firm's snap sacking ruled unfair

She saved a client's $33K deposit. He fired her for talking back

'Get out or I'll call police': law firm's snap sacking ruled unfair

A Gold Coast law firm fired a senior lawyer on the spot and threatened to call police if she refused to leave.

The Fair Work Commission found the worker was unfairly dismissed and ordered Aditum Lawyers Pty Ltd to pay $44,577.13 in compensation plus superannuation, in a decision handed down on November 10, 2026.

The worker had been employed as a senior associate at the small Queensland firm for 14 months. By the time she was shown the door, her full-time role had already been cut to three days a week - then four - without her agreement, and her take-home pay had dropped accordingly.

It started with a staff meeting in April 2025.

The firm's principal had failed to register the firm's trust account on PEXA, the electronic settlement platform used for property transactions, nearly costing a client a $33,000 home deposit. The worker saved the situation by negotiating a new settlement date. But at a 3pm staff meeting that same afternoon - with the PEXA deadline still ticking - the principal mocked her for being stressed, telling her she would "never be a lawyer like me, as in not stressed, calm and collected," according to the decision.

She fired back. Words were exchanged about formal complaints lodged against the principal with the Office of the Legal Services Commissioner. She was told to leave the room. She thought she had been dismissed and started packing. The principal clarified she had not been fired - but told her to go home and "reflect."

What followed was unusual.

The principal sent her a text telling her to "unplug completely from work" and not return until she messaged him the words "im ready." The next morning, he emailed her a list of ten life-coaching-style questions - including "If I died in 5 years, what would I want to be remembered for?" and "What am I avoiding confronting in my life?" - with answers due by close of business the following day.

The worker also received a sealed letter, to be opened on May 1, 2025, announcing a pay rise to $125,000 plus superannuation upon her one-year anniversary. But that same day, the principal told her that her working days would immediately drop from five to three per week. The decision recorded the worker's evidence that she "had no choice" and that the reduction had nothing to do with self-improvement - it was about freeing up budget to hire junior staff.

The Commission found this amounted to a unilateral change from full-time to part-time employment on reduced pay, in breach of the employment contract.

The arrangement created its own problems. The worker was told she could not let clients know she only worked three days. She was not allowed to put an out-of-office message on her email. Clients still called on her days off. As the decision put it, Mondays and Fridays "were not days off for her, they were just days that she was not 'supposed' to work, and was not being paid to work, but still had to be responsive."

Then came the "missiles."

While the principal was overseas in Japan in late June 2025 - having left no instructions about his absence - a client chased up a meeting that the principal himself had proposed weeks earlier. The worker emailed the client that the principal "has become stranded overseas due to the missiles" and offered to call them the next day. She followed up with a correction: "Full disclosure, I was joking about the missiles, I think Carlyon just caught a very boring cold."

The principal did not find it funny. He emailed the worker calling the conduct "wholly inappropriate" and "within the purview of serious misconduct." This came on top of an earlier incident where the worker had told a client she was "stuck in court" on her day off, prompting a lecture from the principal about "radical honesty" - a personal philosophy he applied to the workplace, which involved not tolerating even white lies. As the principal put it at the hearing: "It's my personal belief and the way I want my business run."

The dismissal came on July 29, 2025. The principal walked into the worker's office while on speakerphone with a client, discussing one of her emails - without the client knowing the worker was listening. After the call, he told her he did not like how she spoke to clients. The worker responded that she had been in private practice for 12 years and would not accept that criticism from someone with 200 matters.

The principal told her to get out. When she said she had work to do, he said he would call the police.

She was not told why she was being dismissed. No investigation was conducted. No chance to respond. The firm's own gross misconduct policy - which required the employer to investigate, hear the employee's response, and have a witness present - was not followed. Neither was the suspension clause in her employment contract, which allowed the employer to suspend on full pay while investigating.

The termination letter did not arrive for another 10 days. It listed nine broad reasons for dismissal, none of which had been raised with the worker on the day. A second letter that same day warned her that the firm would "ventilate the matter fully and publicly" if she commenced proceedings, and threatened referrals to the Queensland Police and the "Fixated Persons Investigations Unit" if she kept contacting the firm.

A week after the dismissal, the principal posted on LinkedIn under the title "#Hiring vs #Firing." The post, accompanied by photos of himself styled as two sides of a coin - one labelled "#Hiring" in purple, the other "#Firing" in red - described firing employees who "preferred the early chaos because it gave them cover" and "made excuses" and "avoided accountability."

The Commission found the principal's denials that the post was about the worker were "difficult to sustain." The worker told the hearing it damaged her ability to find another job on the Gold Coast, forcing her to use money from another business she co-owned with her partner to start her own law firm.

At the hearing, the principal struggled to pin down a consistent reason for the dismissal. The stated reason shifted across multiple documents and submissions - from dishonesty to clients, to disobeying a direction, to a culmination of issues over the entire employment. The deputy president had to press the question repeatedly during closing submissions before the principal settled on the worker telling him she would not accept his authority.

The Commission found no valid reason for dismissal, no serious misconduct, and no compliance with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code - the set of minimum steps small employers must follow when terminating someone. There was a total absence of basic procedural fairness. The dismissal was characterised as a "spur of the moment decision" made in an "agitated state."

Compensation was calculated starting at $125,000 - the salary the worker would have earned over the 12 months the Commission estimated she would have stayed. That was reduced by 5% for her sharp response on the day, then by $28,800 in post-dismissal earnings, then by a further 5% for contingencies, arriving at $85,452.50. The legal cap on compensation - based on the worker's actual earnings in the six months before dismissal - brought the final figure down to $44,577.13 plus $5,349.26 in superannuation.

For HR teams in small businesses, this case reads like a step-by-step guide to what not to do: fire in the heat of the moment, retrofit the reasons after the fact, and air your version of events on social media while proceedings are live.

The decision is publicly available. Both parties represented themselves before the Commission.

LATEST NEWS