'Discretionary' or binding? One word cost this employer $366k

The employer read 'access' as a doorway. The court read it as 'obtain'

'Discretionary' or binding? One word cost this employer $366k

A labour hire company argued its profit share clause was discretionary. The Federal Court disagreed - to the tune of $366,405.

HealthX Group Pty Ltd, which runs a health and aged care labour hire business, has lost its bid to overturn a $366,405.20 payout to a former general manager who said the company owed her years of unpaid profit share.

The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia delivered its decision on November 9, upholding the finding that the profit share clause in the employee's contract created a binding entitlement - not something the employer could pay or withhold at its discretion.

The employee ran HealthX's labour hire operation from July 2016 to April 2023. Her contract included a schedule provision - known in the proceedings as Item 10 - entitling her to 5% of the business unit's earnings before interest and tax (EBIT) before shared services costs, so long as four performance "gates" were met: top-line revenue growth, increased profitability, a staff survey showing committed and engaged staff, and improvement in client net promoter scores.

She resigned in April 2023. The fight over that clause - and over a separate restraint of trade provision - landed in court shortly after.

HealthX made the first move. In January 2024, it commenced proceedings seeking declarations that no profit share entitlement existed and an injunction to stop the employee from working for a competitor. The employee cross-claimed for the profit share she said she was owed.

By the time the matter reached trial in September 2025, HealthX had dropped the injunction. The primary judge noted the company had delayed commencing the restraint claim for almost 12 months, never sought urgent relief, and failed to comply with procedural directions - causing original trial dates to be abandoned. By the time the restraint claim was withdrawn, the full two-year restraint period in the contract had already expired.

That left the profit share dispute. HealthX's argument was straightforward: the word "access" in Item 10 meant the employee could only access an "achievable opportunity" to receive a share - language it said was aspirational, not binding. Payment, it argued, rested entirely within the employer's discretion.

The primary judge saw it differently. "Access" was used as a verb meaning "to obtain," not as a noun suggesting a doorway. The phrase about "achievable opportunity" was described as being "in the nature of commentary" that added nothing substantive. And the four gates used the past participle "needed" - a word the primary judge found connoted a one-time threshold, not an ongoing requirement. If the clause had intended the gates to repeat, the judge reasoned, it would have used the future tense: "will need."

A reasonable businessperson, the primary judge held, would have understood that once those gates were met, the profit share was payable. Full stop.

On appeal, HealthX tried a different tack. It pointed to an earlier employment contract with AWX Pty Ltd - the company from which HealthX had been spun out in 2016 - which contained a similar profit share clause but with an extra gate: the business had to be "on or above budget to participate." An associated incentive scheme document from that era reserved "absolute discretion" for management over disputes and changes to the scheme. HealthX argued this earlier contract should inform how Item 10 was read.

The Full Court was not persuaded, for two reasons.

First, HealthX had never raised this argument at trial. It was no part of its case below that Item 10 was ambiguous in a way that could be resolved by looking at the earlier contract. The court could not find error in a conclusion the primary judge was never asked to reach.

Second, even on the merits, the argument did not hold up. The discretionary language in the earlier contract and incentive scheme had not survived into the new one. HealthX was effectively asking the court to read Item 10 "as though it includes the words that featured in the First Employment Contract, notwithstanding that they were quite obviously - and, one must assume, deliberately - omitted."

The Full Court described the primary judge's reasoning as "compelling" and adopted it as its own.

HealthX did win on one point. The primary judge had ordered it to pay the employee's costs thrown away by the abandoned restraint of trade claim, reasoning that the company's delay amounted to unreasonable conduct under section 570 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The Full Court disagreed. The costs the employee incurred arose because HealthX pursued the claim - not because it pursued it slowly. Had the employer moved faster, the employee would likely have spent more on her defence, not less. Negligence and inefficiency, the court observed, are not the same as unreasonableness under the Act.

The result: the $366,405.20 profit share award stands, along with interest and the employee's broader costs. The costs order relating to the abandoned restraint claim was set aside.

For HR teams drafting incentive clauses, the case is a practical reminder that the difference between a binding profit share and a discretionary bonus lives in the actual words on the page. Aspirational preamble does not override operative language - and when the old contract's discretionary terms are left out of the new one, employers cannot read them back in.

The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. No further appeal has been indicated.

LATEST NEWS