Why the manager-employee relationship is dead

Implementing self-managing teams has many benefits, including encouraging people to think like the founder

Why the manager-employee relationship is dead
In 2011, Gary Hamel penned a controversial article for Harvard Business Review called “First, let’s fire all the managers”. Since this article was published, many organisations have begun exploring the concept of self-managing teams and moving to a Holocracy ystem.
Such a system knocks down traditional hierarchy - people no longer have a boss, and people are empowered to make their own decisions (individually or in their teams), as opposed to navigating through numerous approval layers.
My consultancy Inventium, an innovation agency, recently “fired” all the managers and moved to such a system. While there have proved to be many benefits in doing so, here are several that organisations which have implemented self-managing teams have observed.
It encourages people to think like a founder
Traditional management structures are similar to a parent-child relationship – despite the fact that organisations are full of adults.
Managers can be like the authoritative parent who is responsible for determining what is right or wrong, as well as granting permission for the child to engage in certain activities.
In organisations which have eliminated managers, relationships become more adult to adult. In doing so, everyone feels more empowered, more responsible and ultimately, acts more like a Founder than an employee.
It removes blockages
Even though managers may have the best of intentions, they can actually be the cause of blockages and bottlenecks.
For example, if managers (or potentially several layers of managers) need to sign off on decisions employees make, things inevitably take longer to get done.
In today’s world, businesses that are bogged down in bureaucracy lag behind in the innovation race. It is the organisations which are able to be swift and efficient that can release products faster and respond more quickly to customer needs.
It frees up “managers” to focus on what they do best
When people rise up the ranks in organisations, it tends to be because they have superior technical skills. Less often, it is because they are a superb people manager.

Indeed, in most organisations, it is well documented that people leave because of managers, not companies.
As such, it is almost illogical for people who are so technically skilled to be spending a large proportion of their time doing something they are probably not that good at and often don’t enjoy – that is, managing people.
For organisations that have self-managing teams, people who were previously spending a lot of their working hours managing people are now freed up to do what they do best – using the technical skills they have acquired over the course of their career and applying that to doing great work for their company.
Making the move to self-managing teams, or a Holocracy, is a significant one.
Organisational, team and individual structures need to be completely re-thought, ranging from how feedback is given, through to how goals are set and how pay rises are awarded.
But if you can work through the multitude of changes and decisions, the world of self-managing teams can be an incredibly rewarding, empowering and profitable change for companies.
Dr Amantha Imber is the Founder of Inventium, an innovation consultancy that only uses tools that have been scientifically proven to work. Her latest book, The Innovation Formula, tackles the topic of how organisations can create a culture where innovation thrives.
Related stories:
Is your company losing employees due to ‘small subtleties’?

Is it time to get tough on change fatigue?

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up-to-date with the world of HR. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from HRD Australia.

Recent articles & video

What are the priorities of senior leaders today?

Can HR deduct training costs from employees' pay?

HR leadership in an era of instant gratification

How to become moral leaders

Most Read Articles

R U OK? Day: How can HR prepare?

1 in 3 quit over this top employee benefit

Does unlimited annual leave actually work?