Is manager or peer recognition more impactful?

We find out why praise from managers alone is not enough to build a solid, engaging culture

Is manager or peer recognition more impactful?

One of the most common questions we get is this: is manager-given or peer-to-peer recognition more important?

Both forms of recognition are crucial to building a sense of appreciation in your workplace culture, yet companies often forget to incorporate peer-to-peer recognition within their recognition programs. 29%. of employees surveyed have not given recognition in the past month, and 14% never or rarely give recognition at all.

Why peer-to-peer recognition is important
The benefits of peer to peer recognition go far beyond engagement alone. It has the power to:

  • Increase employee engagement

Employees feel they are doing great work and are engaged with their peers. There is a 26% increase in engagement scores when employees give recognition to each other.

  • Build company culture

89% agree that employees giving recognition creates a better company culture. Having a great company culture helps you become a great place to work, increases pride and loyalty from your people, and can be a great recruiting tool to attract top talent.

  • Help foster a sense of connection and belonging

86% percent of employees agree giving recognition helps them better connect with their colleagues, and 81% say it helps them better connect with the organisation. Recognition from peers shows an employee fits in and belongs in the organisation.

  • Lower turnover

75% percent of employees say giving recognition makes them want to stay at their current organisation longer.

  • Improve performance

There is a 33% increase in innovation and 22% increase in work results when employees give recognition.

  • Benefit employee well-being

84% percent say giving recognition improves their personal sense of well-being.

Peer-to-peer program best practices
How do you start implementing peer-to-peer recognition in your organisation? Make it part of your workplace culture.

1. Have a formal, enterprise-wide solution that is more than just an HR perk. When recognition is seen as a culture-building initiative, and not just another workplace benefit, you get more support from senior leaders, more resources, and more impact from your investment. An enterprise-wide solution also allows you to create a consistent experience for employees across locations and departments.

2. Give everyone the opportunity to give and receive recognition. Ensure every employee is aware that you have a peer-to-peer recognition program, and that each person feels empowered to use it to give recognition. Every employee should also have the opportunity to do great work and be recognised, regardless of job title, tenure, or function.

3. Make sure your peer-to-peer recognition program is easy to use and has both mobile and offline capabilities. Employees will want to recognise on the go, 24/7, and at home. Also account for employees who don’t have internet access while at work and may need offline tools to give recognition. And don’t forget remote employees—make sure they have access to tools and opportunities to be recognised too.

4. Publicise recognition. Whether it’s a “wall of fame” feature on your recognition program, highlighting recent achievements on monitors in public spaces, or starting meetings by calling out successes, let others in your organisation see the great work employees are doing.

5. Allow peers to participate in employee celebrations. Whether you are congratulating a major accomplishment or celebrating a service anniversary, invite peers to gather, comment, and be part of the presentation. In best in class companies, employees take the initiative to put together and plan a peer’s recognition moment.

6. Senior leaders should model and remind their people about the importance and impact of recognizing great work. Be a good example and set the tone for what to recognise and how to show appreciation. Encourage your people to do it frequently. Employees look to their leaders to feel empowered and inspired to give recognition.

7. Keep it fresh and top of mind. Provide ongoing communication about your peer-to-peer recognition program. Remind employees to recognise often. 73% of employees would like reminders to recognise at least monthly.

By incorporating peer-to-peer recognition in your organisation, you’ll build a workplace culture where employees feel engaged, connected, and part of a winning team. You’ll create a workplace where employees thrive and work together to achieve success.

Recent articles & video

Deloitte chief talent officer: Why you need an anti-violence policy

There’s been a 42% rise in workplace harassment complaints

How to tell an employee they smell - and other awkward conversations

Want to empower your workers? Stop micromanaging them!

Most Read Articles

HRD Awards Asia 2020 winners revealed

Remote work: Leaders reveal key lessons from pandemic

Cathay Pacific to slash 6,000 jobs amid crisis