Disciplinary action and mental illness

by HRD19 Dec 2017
A rigorous and formal disciplinary process can have a “devastating” impact on someone with a mental illness, according to Campbell Fisher, managing partner and solicitor director at FCB Group.

When an employee has a mental illness and a formalised performance management process is being contemplated the first question to be asked is whether the employee is capable of participating, he tells HRD.

“It’s important to question whether somebody with a mental illness is actually well enough to properly respond to a process and make decisions for themselves,” says Fisher.

“That’s always a difficult issue. Essentially it is a medical question rather than a legal question, but it’s something that people often don’t pay enough attention to.

“Instead, they just launch straight into a process and wonder why it doesn’t go very well.”

Fisher says that determining whether an employee is well enough to participate in the process should be conducted through an independent medical assessment, particularly if the person is contending that they are not well enough.

He adds that there are a range of structures that can be added to a process to ensure it is objective and as fair as possible.

“Obviously if there are interpersonal issues at play you might want to introduce some different people to the process,” says Fisher.

“You would normally offer the person who is going through the process a support person so that they can be supported through the process.

“If the person is really unwell you have got to assess whether the process itself places them at further risk of harm and whether it is also manageable for the people who are involved in the process with them.” 

So what type of support does someone with a mental illness really need during performance management?

“Lots of organisations have employee assistance programs [EAPs], which allow you to separate the support and treatment of the mental health condition vis a vis the work issues,” he says.

Fisher adds that it can be stressful managing a person with serious mental health issues, particularly if they may threaten to self-harm.

“It can be not only a danger to them but also to the people around them who take on the responsibility of trying to ensure that they don’t do that,” he says.

“People who have mental health issues sometimes operate in unpredictable ways and the obligation of organisations is not only to protect their health and safety at work but also the other people at work.”

Related stories:
Australian workers want less stress 
Employees putting in five hours per week of overtime


  • by Francis 19/12/2017 4:49:41 PM

    As a Psychologist who works with those inflicted with work place harassment dressed up as performance issues I sometimes wonder who has the greater psychological challenges - the Managers or the Managed. I have dealt with situations in which a very junior staff member has been summonsed (no agenda) to a 'performance' meeting with three levels of management and HR present, each making sure the 'process' was being followed. I kid you not! This person, not surprisingly, then broke down under the unexplained pressure and perceived stigma of being at fault. A $35k job. The lower down the pecking order, the greater the scrutiny. This space will soon erupt.

    BTW it's vis a vis not Kath and Kim's visa vie.

Most Read