Fired bus driver wins unfair dismissal case - but gets nothing

CCTV told one story. The termination letter skipped a step

Fired bus driver wins unfair dismissal case - but gets nothing

A casual bus driver who clashed with a bus marshal on a packed Sydney service has had his dismissal declared unfair - but the Fair Work Commission declined to award him a cent. 

The decision, handed down on November 12, 2026, turned not on what happened on the bus but on what happened afterwards. U-Go Mobility terminated the driver without ever putting the allegations to him or giving him a chance to respond. 

The driver started with U-Go Mobility in April 2024, picking up casual shifts - mostly Saturdays - driving buses out of the Revesby depot. Over 22 months he worked 79 shifts. Not a heavy workload, but enough for the Commission to find he qualified as a regular casual employee entitled to unfair dismissal protection. 

That finding alone was contested. U-Go Mobility argued the shifts were too sporadic to count. The Commission disagreed, finding the driver worked at least one day in 11 of his final 12 weeks, and that the company's own rostering system - weekly emails asking casuals to nominate their availability - created a systematic pattern. One email even invited employees to nominate for route shifts during an Ed Sheeran concert. 

Shortly before his dismissal, a depot operations manager had offered to teach the driver additional routes so he could pick up more work. That, the Commission found, only reinforced his reasonable expectation of ongoing employment. 

Then came February 7, 2026. 

The trouble on the bus 

The driver was operating a busy service when passengers began boarding without tapping their Opal cards. One arrived with a coffee and stood drinking it in the doorway, blocking the queue. Another boarded without paying at all. The driver told that passenger to leave. 

A bus marshal stepped in - but not gently. CCTV footage reviewed by the Commission showed the marshal approached the driver's cabin in a confrontational manner, demanded to know why he was "yelling at customers," and positioned himself aggressively inside the confined space around the driver's seat. 

The Commission found the driver had been firm with passengers but was not yelling at them. 

What followed was a rapid escalation. The marshal grabbed the driver's arm. The driver pushed the marshal away. Expletives flew in both directions. Passengers started filming. Eventually everyone left the bus, and the driver completed the route alone. 

The Commission accepted the marshal's conduct was "unacceptable" and "confrontational from the outset," and that the marshal initiated the physical contact. But it also found the driver's response - pushing the marshal and trading insults - was neither necessary nor reasonable, even under stress. 

That gave U-Go Mobility a valid reason for dismissal. 

Where the employer tripped up 

The problem was process, not substance. After the incident, the company's area manager called the driver on February 9 and directed him to attend an investigation meeting. He asked if it could be done by phone. She said no. She emailed him directions to attend at the Revesby depot on February 11. 

The driver asked if the meeting could be held at Kingsgrove instead. The manager said no. He then proposed rescheduling to February 14, explaining he had a commitment on the 11th, and asked her to let him know. 

She did not respond. U-Go Mobility terminated him the next day. 

The termination letter listed the allegations - aggressive tone toward passengers and marshals, physical contact with a marshal, inappropriate language - and cited "a thorough investigation." But the driver had never been shown those allegations before the letter arrived. He never got the chance to tell his side. 

The Commission noted U-Go Mobility had 666 employees and dedicated HR resources at the time. There was no excuse for the procedural shortcut. 

Unfair, but not worth a dollar 

Despite finding the dismissal procedurally unfair, the Commission ordered no compensation. The reasoning was blunt: even if a fair process had been followed, the driver would have been dismissed anyway on the strength of his conduct. The Commission estimated a proper process would have taken about two weeks - during which the driver would not have been rostered to work and would therefore have earned nothing. 

The driver had already landed a new job by May 2026, working casual hours but at full-time volume, and earning more than he had at U-Go Mobility. 

For HR teams, the case puts the point plainly: a valid reason for dismissal does not make up for a broken process - but a broken process does not guarantee a payout either, especially when the employee's own conduct gave the employer the reason in the first place. 

LATEST NEWS