Toll driver wore smart glasses at gas terminal - then fought his firing

The driver admitted doing the wrong thing, but blamed retaliation

Toll driver wore smart glasses at gas terminal - then fought his firing

A tanker driver who wore smart glasses at a highly flammable gas terminal lost his bid to prove Toll Transport sacked him as payback for workplace complaints. 

The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia dismissed the driver's claim on November 13, finding his employer's real motivation for the termination was a serious safety breach - not the grievances he had raised. 

The smart glasses that started it all 

The worker drove LPG tankers under a contract Toll held with Origin Energy. His job involved loading product at the Long Island Point (LIP) terminal, operated by Esso Australia. That terminal had a zero-tolerance policy on electronic devices. LPG is highly flammable, and electronic devices can generate sparks capable of igniting it. 

On June 17, 2025, the driver used a pair of smart glasses to photograph a control panel at the terminal and sent the images to his managers. He knew the risk - the court noted he had tried to cover the smart glasses with safety glasses to reduce the danger. 

The fallout was swift. Esso locked the driver out of the terminal. Origin pulled him from its work entirely. An email from an Origin representative said the driver needed to be removed from Origin work "as soon as possible" because his "attitude is poor." Within a day, the driver had no work available to him. 

The timeline that sank the claim 

The driver filed his first workplace complaint on June 20, 2025, raising concerns about safety conditions, truck allocations, and management's handling of an earlier truck fire. He filed a second complaint on June 25, requesting assurance that he would not face retaliation for making safety disclosures. 

But he had already been off the roster since June 18 - two full days before his first complaint. The court found this chronology fatal to the first limb of his claim. The driver accepted as much in his own submissions, conceding that "the first roster omission and the initial stand-down communication on 19 June 2025 occurred before the two Complaints fixed for trial." 

Suspension and show cause 

Toll suspended the driver on June 30, 2025, pending an investigation into the smart glasses incident. A national manager recommended the suspension to the general manager of the business unit, who approved it. 

The court acknowledged a timing overlap between the complaints and the suspension. The national manager who recommended it knew about at least the first complaint. But the driver himself accepted in evidence that the use of electronic devices at the terminal was a serious safety matter, that Toll was entitled to investigate it, and that suspending him was reasonable. 

That concession proved telling. 

An investigation followed. On July 9, Toll informed the driver it had found his conduct breached the company's code of practice, health and safety policy, workplace behaviours policy, and his contract of employment. He was handed a show-cause letter asking why his employment should not be terminated. 

In his written response on July 14, the driver said "it is possible that my judgment during the LIP incident was affected by the unresolved trauma of that prior event" - a reference to the truck fire earlier that year. Asked in cross-examination what he meant, he said: "I know I did the wrong thing." 

His employment was terminated on July 25, 2025. 

Why the claim failed 

Under section 361 of the Fair Work Act, an employer bears the burden of proving its reasons for adverse action once an employee shows the evidence is consistent with a retaliation theory. That reverse onus never kicked in here. The court found the driver had not cleared even that initial threshold - largely because of his own evidence. 

His strongest argument was that some of the people who investigated his complaints also played a role in the disciplinary process. The court accepted that overlap existed and called it a relevant consideration. But it was not determinative. What mattered was what was actually in the minds of the decision-makers. 

The three people who made or influenced the termination decision - the national manager, the general manager, and a vice president of HR - all gave evidence that the smart glasses incident was the substantial and operative reason for the dismissal. None of them were challenged on those reasons in cross-examination. The court accepted their evidence. 

From start to finish, Toll treated the safety breach consistently: an internal incident report was filed on June 18, HR support was engaged on June 19, the driver was confronted directly on June 24, and every letter in the disciplinary chain referenced the glasses incident. All of that began before any complaint was made. 

The court dismissed the application in its entirety. 

For HR teams managing parallel complaints and disciplinary processes, the case is a practical reminder that chronology, consistency, and documentation can be the difference between a defensible termination and an adverse action finding. 

LATEST NEWS