She compared a colleague to a reality TV star. Then her employer went digging
A government worker's mocking GIF cost her a formal warning - but the Fair Work Commission found her employer went too far when it trawled through her private messages looking for more ammunition.
The decision, handed down on November 12, 2026, resolved three disputes between a long-serving Victorian public servant and the State Revenue Office. The worker had spent more than 30 years in the Victorian Public Service and managed a team of 12 as Branch Manager, Learning and Development - a senior role responsible for culture change and leadership capability across the organisation.
The trouble started with a GIF.
On October 14, 2024, the worker posted an image of Big Ed - a character from the reality TV show 90 Day Fiance whom the Commission described as "a figure of ridicule" - to her team's group chat on Microsoft Teams. She followed it with a message asking whether anyone else thought the image looked like a branch manager from another section of the SRO.
That branch manager was not in the chat. He found out anyway, and raised concerns with the worker's executive director. A team member later filed a separate formal complaint about the same message.
From there, things escalated. The SRO sought and received approval from its Deputy Commissioner to search the team's group chat. According to the Commission's findings, after not finding anything particularly offensive there, the SRO then sought approval to search all team chats involving the worker - including private one-on-one conversations. The search produced ten separate instances of messaging the SRO considered potentially inappropriate, spanning July to November 2024.
The worker was handed a notice of allegations on December 19, 2024 - just before Christmas shutdown. An external investigator found five of the ten particulars substantiated and one partially substantiated. On April 16, 2025, the worker received a final warning. The accompanying letter described the conduct as "serious misconduct."
Separately, a direct report had filed a formal complaint back in August 2024, alleging unpredictable and bullying behaviour. That complaint went through mediation first, which ended after roughly an hour when the parties could not agree on its purpose. The mediator eventually confirmed the process had concluded without agreement, and the complainant withdrew consent to continue. The SRO then moved to a formal investigation, which produced a written warning.
On top of both disciplinary matters, the worker was also going through a performance improvement process. When she raised mental health concerns - including a psychologist's letter stating that workplace pressure was "proving to be counterproductive, adversely affecting her work performance and overall well-being" - the SRO directed her to attend an independent medical examination. She objected to some of the questions, particularly around disclosing the nature of her condition.
The Commission dealt with all three disputes together.
On the IME direction, the Commission found the employer was entitled to require it under clause 57 of the Victorian Public Service Enterprise Agreement 2024. The worker had repeatedly raised mental health concerns, her psychologist had flagged that workplace pressure was affecting her performance, and her executive director had paused the performance improvement process after receiving the psychologist's letter. The Commission found this amounted to a genuine concern about the worker's capacity to perform her duties. It noted that objectively, a reasonable employer would share that concern given the information available.
On the MS Teams disciplinary matter, the Commission drew a sharp line between the Big Ed GIF and everything else.
The GIF was fair game. The Commission found the image was plainly unflattering and that comparing a colleague to it in a group chat was objectively disrespectful. The worker's insistence that she could not see why it was disrespectful showed "poor judgement" for someone in a senior culture and leadership role. She eventually conceded in cross-examination that posting it in the group chat was wrong.
The other messages were a different story.
The Commission found the SRO's process of searching through the worker's private chats did not comply with the enterprise agreement's misconduct management requirements. As the Commission put it, the SRO appeared to be "retroactively seeking examples to bolster a complaint." Comments in a private one-on-one conversation, it noted, are quite different to comments in a group chat. And the messages had been pulled from their conversational context, stripping away the back-and-forth that gave them meaning.
On the evidence, the Commission also found it did not appear that permission had been given to search one-on-one chats outside the period of November 1 to December 9, 2024 - yet the allegations reached back to July.
Critically, the worker was never told that no one had actually complained about the private messages. The Commission drew a clear distinction: there is a meaningful difference between a colleague raising a concern about something said to them and an employer sifting through chat logs and "plucking out messages the SRO is unhappy with."
Even setting aside the process failures, the Commission found a formal warning over the private messages was disproportionate. The messages amounted to "expressions of frustration, petty banter and sarcastic comments" in conversations never meant for a wider audience. At most, they warranted an informal discussion.
The result: the final warning was removed and replaced with a standard written warning relating only to the Big Ed GIF. On its own, the Commission held, one inappropriate group chat message was not serious misconduct and did not warrant a final warning.
On the communication complaint, the Commission found the SRO's process largely complied with the enterprise agreement. The ten-month timeline from complaint to outcome was not completed "as quickly as practicable," the Commission noted, but the delays did not prejudice the worker's ability to respond. The warning stood.
Across all three matters, the Commission observed that the SRO had not conducted welfare checks on the worker despite her repeatedly flagging mental health struggles while simultaneously facing multiple disciplinary processes and a performance improvement plan. The enterprise agreement did not strictly require welfare checks, but the Commission noted that independent welfare support "may have alleviated some of" the worker's stress.
For HR teams, the practical signal is plain: using a specific complaint as a springboard to search through months of private one-on-one workplace messages, without anyone having complained about those conversations, risks turning a legitimate investigation into something a tribunal will not accept - and any discipline built on that foundation may not survive.