Off-the-shelf leadership programs have their place in today’s workplace, but as DLPA’s Karlie Cremin argues, going bespoke can result in more strategically targeted leaders
It’s a combination of disciplines that HR managers may do well to heed when it comes to implementing leadership development programs. “Our whole service offering was formulated on the basis of bringing those two vantage points – strategy and the people within an organisation – into leadership development programs,” Cremin explains.
“What we noticed is that, when profit drivers in particular were clearly identified, interrogated and used to inform the formulation of a leadership development program, organisations were seeing changes not only in terms of team dynamic and capability of staff, but also in the bottom line and other performance metrics.”
A road less travelled
There is little quality research data available to back up the use of bespoke programs over off-the-shelf alternatives, primarily because of the difficulty in measuring success with all of the variables involved. However, academics like Richard Bolden at the University of the West of England have hypothesized what could be seen as common sense to most HR professionals: that leadership development programs are likely to have a higher impact when contextual and organisational factors are considered in their design. Martha Gephart and Victoria Marsick at Columbia University in New York have also noted higher levels of success in leadership development when learning tools have been adjusted after the collection and analysis of data, thus creating enhanced strategic leverage points in the organisation.
There’s just one problem. While DLPA’s assumptions have been borne out by practical experience since 1999, businesses typically start by wanting off-the-shelf options. “Most businesses don’t actively seek a bespoke option,” Cremin says. “The current economic environment means that cost is front of mind for businesses, and bespoke sounds expensive. For this reason, very few actually seek bespoke options.”
It is the quest for ROI that often encourages a shift towards bespoke programs. “Ultimately, businesses pick bespoke options because they are looking for higher returns, and they see how these programs would work for them.” In the end, Cremin says bespoke leadership development options only work if there is a real and genuine commitment from a business to critically assess what makes it profitable. “If they aren’t willing to do that, bespoke options won’t yield anything significantly higher than an off-the-shelf option. Bespoke programs require an open and honest appraisal of the business as it currently is and a willingness to change your point of view.”
An uncomfortable truth
If there is a common theme to what businesses seek from bespoke programs, Cremin says it is about getting their leadership teams comfortable with being uncomfortable. “Ultimately, I think businesses want to go through a process with their leadership team that allows them to sit in discomfort and take the required action anyway, so that they can act as a positive change agent within the organisation,” Cremin says.
This applies to the business as well. The creation of a bespoke program can involve workshops with key stakeholders determining current circumstances, aspirations and the overall business strategy, as well as workforce assessments, which can include interviews, cultural and employee engagement surveys, and 360 assessments. The business is asked to open itself to scrutiny, so the program supports the overall strategy.
The result is often a mix of both hard and soft leadership training, delivered through workshops, team building, coaching, mentoring and even retreats. With an expanding pool of capacities required of leaders today – from staples like time management, conflict resolution and communication to the increasingly important harnessing of discretionary effort, unconscious bias, and having the hard conversations – Cremin says constant improvement is required in both technical and non-technical skill areas.
A strategic tool
For those that choose a bespoke program, DLPA’s Cremin says there can be a big difference in the way it works within a business.
Two scenarios illustrate this point:
Strategy 1: Seeking customer service excellence
A business may identify a strategy of excellence in customer service to gain a larger market share, as well as the fact that their leaders are poor at convincing others to buy in to change.
Rather than clipping together preset parts, like a general communication workshop, a persuasion workshop and a necessary customer service workshop, a bespoke program will first assess whether the customer service strategy is appropriate to the business, and then involve staff in the formulation of the program that will support them through implementation. With staff enrolled in the strategy from the outset, they are likely to be committed to doing what is required to be successful.
In some cases leaders undergoing training may – after the communication workshop for example – become aloof and disgruntled. Though an off-the-shelf program would either stop entirely or keep on going regardless, a bespoke option would seek to collect data and locate the root cause of the change in attitude, and the subsequent program activities would be altered to mitigate the change. This might mean a revised order, changing the style of coaching or even completely changing the content, to ensure that the program continues to align with the strategy and assists with implementation.
Strategy 2: Seeking aggressive growth
Many companies want to capture strong growth through better leadership. In a bespoke program, this would mean drilling down through the detail of the strategy to identify capacity issues, planning issues, skills gaps and any other issues that may reduce the effectiveness of the implementation of that strategy in that particular organisation. Through the use of this data, the organisation can develop a program that ensures staff are equipped to deliver the strategic outcomes for the business, which will in turn result in a more responsive and agile business or business unit that is better equipped to respond to changing market conditions while keeping an eye on the ultimate goal.
A bespoke future
When DLPA first began, Cremin says only 5% of new clients would come through the door asking for a bespoke program. That has now risen to 20% of the market, though Cremin says the bulk of the remaining 80% quickly convert to a bespoke option.
This may increase in a future where program outcomes are likely to be the primary measure of returns, as the economy rewards more strategically focused businesses.
“I believe the organisations that will thrive in future will be agile, responsive and lean,” Cremin says. “Part of this model has to be leveraging the power of people to closely serve the strategy. HR managers will need to keep this in mind when selecting development programs to ensure they select products that produce the best results.
“For programs to be effective you need to be very outcomes-focused. When you then couple that with using the overall strategy of the business to inform the outcomes you are seeking, you significantly increase your return.
Why would you do anything else?”
Dynamic Leadership Programs Australia (DLPA) is a bespoke leadership and business development program provider that drives strategic objectives and unlocks the potential of current and emerging leaders. With corporate strategy at the heart of DLPA’s programs, our team works hand in hand with each client to identify key barriers to their success, develop leadership skills, align organisational values, and empower people to reach higher levels of performance.
For further information on DLPA, click here