The employer ticked every contractual box but forgot to bring the evidence
A Wellington restaurant tried to stop a former employee from opening a competing Malaysian eatery - but its case collapsed over one missing ingredient.
The friendship that became a franchise pitch
Praise Manna Limited has operated Little Penang in central Wellington for about 15 years, earning a reputation for authentic Penang street food. The restaurant's co-owner had known its future general manager for two decades - the pair met while working in banking in Malaysia.
That friendship eventually turned into a job offer. In 2022, the co-owner reached out and suggested the woman visit New Zealand to assess the business. After a visit of just over three weeks, the pair agreed on a plan: the company would sponsor a work visa, the woman would take on a general manager role, and there was an understanding - disputed by the employee - that she might eventually buy into the business or help develop a franchise model.
She started in July 2023. Her employment agreement included clauses covering confidential information, intellectual property, conflict of interest, and a three-month non-solicitation period. There was no general restraint of trade.
From franchise builder to competitor
In her 17 months with the company, the general manager became closely involved in operational strategy. She sat in on franchise development meetings and had input into franchise pricing when the company helped a former employee set up a concept restaurant called Sri Penang on the Terrace - intended as a test model for broader franchising plans.
Then, in October 2024, she resigned, citing what she described as a difficult working environment with excessive hours and a lack of breaks. Her last day was December 14, 2024. The company had the option to place her on garden leave - a period of paid notice where the employee stays home - but chose not to use it.
Two months later, in February 2025, she and her husband opened One Bowl and Plate - a Malaysian restaurant near the top of Lambton Quay, also in central Wellington, trading through a company called Payox Limited.
The employer was not impressed.
A whole menu of alleged breaches
The company took the matter to the Employment Relations Authority, claiming the former general manager had breached her employment agreement on multiple fronts - confidentiality, intellectual property, conflict of interest, and non-solicitation. It also claimed a former chef who later joined One Bowl and Plate had breached similar obligations, and that the general manager's husband and Payox Limited had helped bring about those breaches.
The company pointed to what it said were striking similarities between the two restaurants in setup, decor, menu, and media presence. It argued the general manager had used franchise knowledge, supplier relationships, contractor contacts, and operational know-how gained during her employment to set up a competing business.
It also claimed she had asked kitchen staff about recipes while still on the payroll, and that the chef had recorded recipes and preparation methods before moving to the rival restaurant.
No evidence on the table
In a determination issued on November 17, 2026, the Authority found the company's case had a fundamental gap.
It accepted that the general manager had been exposed to commercially sensitive strategic information as part of her role. But exposure was not the question. The question was whether she had actually misused any of it - and that required proof.
The company did not produce any of the confidential information it claimed had been misused. No franchise pricing documents. No operational requirement records. No supplier details warranting protection. No recipes - written or otherwise - alleged to have been taken or replicated. No suppliers came forward to support the company's claim that they had been misled.
The Authority noted it has broad powers to protect confidential material during proceedings - but none of that machinery was needed because nothing was put forward to assess.
On the recipe front, the evidence was thin. One kitchen employee described the general manager asking to help cook coconut rice on a single occasion. Another initially said she had asked about curry ingredients on multiple occasions but conceded at the hearing it was twice. The Authority found it unreasonable that such limited interactions could allow someone to replicate dishes to a commercial standard - especially when another of the company's own witnesses said he had learned the restaurant's recipes through years of constant practice in the kitchen.
The chef's position
The former chef had worked at the company from January 2021 until February 2025, having agreed to stay on past his resignation in early September 2024 at the company's request. He was Malaysian, had over 20 years of experience as a chef, and had worked at five other Malaysian restaurants in Wellington.
The Authority found no evidence he was involved in setting up One Bowl and Plate before he started working there on March 18, 2025 - by which time the restaurant had already been open for about a month. The company produced no evidence of recorded recipes or preparation methods, despite claiming they existed.
The Authority was not satisfied the chef had breached any of his employment agreement obligations.
The rest breaks claim falls short too
With no breaches found against either former employee, the claims against the husband and Payox Limited fell away.
The two former employees had also brought their own claim, arguing the company had failed to provide paid rest breaks required under section 69ZD of the Employment Relations Act 2000. The Authority found this was not credible. Multiple witnesses - including one called by the respondents - confirmed the company provided staff meals and that employees could sit and eat, often as a group, without pay deductions. The chef accepted he took smoke breaks. The general manager herself accepted she had some responsibility for making sure staff took breaks.
The result
All of the company's claims were dismissed. The rest breaks claim also failed. No remedies or penalties were ordered. Costs were reserved, with the Authority noting that the respondents were self-represented and their personal preparation time is not recoverable - suggesting costs may simply lie where they fall.
For HR teams, the case is a pointed reminder that employment agreement clauses are only as strong as the evidence behind them. Asserting that confidential information existed and was misused, without producing any of it for assessment, left the employer with nothing the Authority could act on.