Dairy employer docks holidays after ordering worker to stay on Christmas standby

The storeman skipped his holidays to wait by the phone as instructed

Dairy employer docks holidays after ordering worker to stay on Christmas standby

A New Zealand dairy company has been ordered to pay a former worker more than $9,000 after the Employment Relations Authority found it wrongly deducted annual leave, failed to pay sick leave during his notice period, and shortchanged his final holiday pay.

The determination, issued on November 6, 2026, went against Kaipi Dairy Products Limited on every count.

The worker had been employed as a storeman since September 2021, earning $33.00 per hour and typically working a 40-hour week. The trouble started over Christmas.

On standby, not on holiday

The previous year, Kaipi had issued a formal closedown notice for the Christmas break - the kind required under New Zealand's Holidays Act. For the 2024/25 period, no such notice was issued. Instead, the company's production manager told the worker to stay on standby from December 23 in case orders came in.

He did as he was told. He stayed available, did not go away, and was not given the chance to rest. Kaipi then deducted six days of annual leave from his entitlement anyway.

The Authority found that was wrong. The worker should have been paid his ordinary rate for those six days without any leave deducted. He was not on holiday. He was waiting by the phone.

That was not the end of it. When the worker came back on January 6, 2025, a company director told him production was "up in the air" and there would be no work until further notice. Kaipi kept him on standby again until production resumed on February 14, paying him 40 hours a week throughout.

The resignation and the sick leave dispute

Ten days after returning to work, the worker resigned. On February 24, 2025, his wife sent two text messages to the director on his behalf: one attaching a medical certificate finding him unfit for work for 14 days, and a second giving his two weeks' notice.

Kaipi's position was that the worker was not entitled to sick leave pay because he had already resigned, the medical certificate was dated after the resignation, and the worker said he would not work out his notice.

The Authority disagreed. The notice period ran through to March 7, 2025 - days that would otherwise have been working days. The worker had a medical certificate covering the period. And his sick leave balance was well in credit: after more than three years of service and only seven sick days taken, he had 18 days available.

Using the average daily pay formula under the Holidays Act, the Authority calculated his sick leave entitlement at $2,781.62 gross.

The holiday pay shortfall

The final issue was the big one.

Over three years the worker had accrued 12 weeks of annual leave and taken only six, leaving six weeks outstanding. His final payslip showed "termination pay" of $5,144.70 - but the Authority calculated his actual entitlement at $11,438.57, using the higher of two rates required under the Holidays Act.

That left a gap of $6,293.87.

The employer's silence

Kaipi filed a brief statement in reply but did not lodge supporting documents and took no further steps. The Authority noted it had received directions, been warned of the consequences, and been told the matter would proceed on the available information.

It proceeded. The worker succeeded on every claim.

The order

Kaipi was ordered to pay the worker $9,075.49 gross (less PAYE) within 28 days, covering the sick leave arrears and the holiday pay shortfall. The company was also ordered to reimburse the worker's $71.55 filing fee.

For HR teams, the case is a compact illustration of how standby is not leave, sick leave entitlements survive a resignation notice, and Holidays Act calculations have real teeth when they go wrong - even for a single employee at a small operation.

LATEST NEWS