“Corporate psychopaths”: How to handle negative online employee reviews

Employees are leaving scathing reviews about managers and HR professionals on job review websites. How can (and should) you respond if you have been criticised online?

“Corporate psychopaths”: How to handle negative online employee reviews
Employees aren’t pulling any punches when it comes to reviewing their workplaces online.

According to anonymous reviews on the employer rating website Glassdoor, National Australia Bank is “an environment perfect for nurturing corporate psychopaths”, while BHP Billiton is “a textbook example of bureaucracy, office politics, dysfunctional communication and operational inefficiency”, the Sydney Morning Herald reported.

So how seriously should business take scathing online reviews?

Randstad strategic account director Mike Roddy told HRM that while such complaints shouldn’t be ignored, employers must be mindful of how much focus to give them and not to go over the top in terms of their reaction.

“You’ve got to be mindful of what is being said out there, whether it’s online or not. Some of the key things you need look at as an organisation with your employment brand is, is there a volume of complaints out there?

“And if there is, is there a particular trend in the number or theme? Is it a particular issue about communication, is it to do with performance management, pay, environment, safety?  This is ABC of leadership, you’ve got to know what is being said about you and whether it has any resonance.”

He said there wasn’t much employers could do if reviews were posted anonymously, but if there were names attached to them, it was important to manage the issue in “real time”.

“You try to take it offline in the sense that you get in contact with the individual, or somebody in the organisation does, and seek to calm the waters a little bit there.

“Never get into an online war, you’ve really got to take it offline as quickly as possible.”

He said the nature of social media meant that complaining employees could gather lots of followers in a short time and it could lead to people who were not connected to the company forming a negative impression of the brand.

If a business was looking at publicly stating a position on an employee complaint, it would have to consider whether the subject matter had enough propulsion to make it to the broader media, where it could affect the customer base and potential future employees.

“The key for any business is to try to reduce the risk of online complaints. With technology today, people can complain in a medium that is very difficult to address in a private way so it gets out there pretty quickly. The new rules of engagement are that you do it in real time and you do it quickly.”

Ways businesses could minimise the risk of complaints included having a strong employment brand proposition that was a living practice, rather than a framed statement on the wall, said Roddy.

“Most businesses fail when they prescribed a set of values and objectives that are not into the DNA of the place and that’s when you start to get culture problems. Anybody in a leadership position really has to embody those values and objectives of the business.”

Doing “stay” interviews to find out how employees feel about their jobs and take the temperature of the organisation was important, as was conducting exit interviews to find out why people left.

“Sometimes people will give you the real reason, sometimes they won’t, but at least it provides the opportunity that if there’s a serious grievance, it will certainly be aired there. If you’re leading your team as effectively as you can day to day, you’ll find no surprises.

“You’re never going to please everyone at every moment of every day, but at least you can minimise the fall-out in the event that you do get someone disgruntled [complaining].”

Have you had to deal with online employee complaints? What did you do?

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up-to-date with the world of HR. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from HRD New Zealand.

Recent articles & video

Conducting reference checks: What you need to know

How can employers support staff in a time of tragedy?

The benefits and pitfalls of a 'four-day work week'

Are employees on maternity leave entitled to accrue leave?

Most Read Articles

Inside Krispy Kreme's recruitment strategy

Are employees on maternity leave entitled to accrue leave?

Is your workplace culture toxic?