The school wanted even its own headmaster's name suppressed
A deputy headmaster dismissed after a Year 11 ski camp went wrong has had his unfair dismissal case partially sealed by the Fair Work Commission.
The teacher had worked at Orange Anglican Grammar School in regional New South Wales since January 2016, moving into the deputy headmaster role the following month. In November 2025, the Anglican Schools Corporation - which runs the school as one of its 18 campuses - let him go.
The reasons? Three of them. The school said he had not carried out a proper risk assessment or put appropriate management measures in place for the 2024 Snow and Tertiary Experience Camp. It also said he had failed to properly manage a child-related incident at the camp, and that he had breached confidentiality directions during the investigation that followed.
He filed for unfair dismissal 12 days later, seeking reinstatement or, failing that, compensation.
Then came the fight over names
Before the main case could be decided, the proceedings hit a threshold question: who gets to be named?
The school operator applied for broad confidentiality orders under the Fair Work Act. It wanted a blanket ban on publishing the names of current or former staff, students, parents, and school council members. It also wanted - unusually - that ban to extend to the applicant himself, cutting him off from seeing those names.
A witness for the school, its Director of People, Culture and Communications, described the "extensive and overlapping connections between staff, students and families" in the school community. She warned that public identification could heighten concerns about professional reputation and compound psychological risks "beyond the immediate workplace."
The applicant pushed back on every front.
His submissions argued there was no automatic right to confidentiality in Commission proceedings and no evidence that anyone's wellbeing would actually be compromised. He also questioned whether Orange - a city of roughly 42,000 people - could fairly be called a small regional community. And he called the proposed orders "excessive," pointing out they would even suppress the well-known identity of the school's headmaster.
The Commission splits the difference
In its decision handed down on November 20, 2026, the Commission landed somewhere in the middle.
It granted the core confidentiality order. People who took part in interviews or the school's internal review process were likely unaware their names might end up in public proceedings, the Commission found. The risk of psychological harm was "speculative," it acknowledged, but still "a relevant, and important, factor." The potential consequences, it added, "may go beyond mere embarrassment or reputational damage for some persons named in the documents."
But the Commission carved out three notable exceptions.
First, it rejected the school's bid to cut the applicant off from seeing the names - a restriction it did not consider desirable. Second, it excluded the school's headmaster, Reverend Stringer, from the order entirely, finding his identity was already publicly known and that naming him was desirable "given the subject matter of these proceedings and his central role in many of the allegations" and in the interests of open justice. Third, it ruled that anyone who had filed a witness statement was not covered by the suppression order, reasoning those individuals "should have presumed and ought to have known or been advised that their witness evidence and identity would likely be public."
The order was also extended to cover names of other schools not operated by the respondent and their employees. Certain portions of the hearing transcript were separately suppressed.
What it means for HR teams
For HR professionals, the decision is a practical reminder on two fronts: confidentiality during internal investigations does not automatically carry over into external proceedings, and employers seeking to shield staff from psychological harm in litigation will need evidence of actual risk - not just the assertion of it - to get more than a partial order.