ServiceNow’s Chief Learning Officer Jayney Howson explains why employees need space to think without AI
Junior employees have traditionally learned to think by doing the unglamorous work. They drafted the first version, sorted through the data and made the call, then lived with the outcome. Increasingly, AI can do much of that work for them. But as those tasks disappear, so do some of the opportunities to develop the judgment that comes with doing them.
There’s growing concern that overreliance on AI could come at a cost. The 2026 International AI Safety Report, written by more than 100 independent experts from over 30 countries, found early evidence that relying on AI tools can weaken critical thinking. Employees are noticing the risks, too. An IBM Institute for Business Value study of 1,500 CHROs and 8,800 employees found that 60% of employees worry AI is eroding their skills, with critical thinking cited most often as declining. HRD America has also reported on researchers warning that AI could erode a workforce’s ability to think.
For employers, the challenge is figuring out how to give people the benefits of AI without letting it do all the thinking for them. At ServiceNow, that means building opportunities into employee learning to work through problems without AI.
Jayney Howson, Chief Learning Officer at ServiceNow in England, believes those opportunities are particularly important for early-career employees, who are still developing the judgment and critical thinking skills they’ll need throughout their careers.
“In order for people to think with AI, you need to create space for them to think without AI and learn without AI and purposefully build those moments into the programming that you do,” Howson said.
Building space to think without AI
Howson said organizations can’t simply talk about the risk, because people naturally take the easiest route to getting work done.
“We go for the least path of resistance in everything that we do as humans. We will find the easiest path to get something done,” she said. “So if AI makes it feel like we’ve got that path, then we’ll take it. So we have to put purposeful barriers in place for our people so that they’re forced to think and to build that judgment muscle.”
Other organizations are reaching similar conclusions. Gartner has urged employers to add productive friction through hands-on exercises and simulated experiences so employees keep practicing critical skills, and PwC now pairs a human skill with every technical AI skill it teaches.
ServiceNow also lets people move more slowly to understand a problem first, Howson said.
“Not only are we okay with it, we’re celebrating it when someone sticks with the problem, really tries to understand it, moves a bit slower to make sure it’s right, and then has the courage to keep iterating on something,” Howson added.
What a mind gym looks like
The company calls this approach the mind gym. Howson said the name borrows from what happened when work moved from factories to desks and gyms grew to keep people fit.
“We are going to start to see the same thing with cognitive decline,” she said. “So as we offload to AI, how do we make sure that we create those really purposeful moments where you build those muscles?”
Howson said the mind gym is a concept rather than a product, and it takes shape through ServiceNow University, the company’s learning platform. Some lessons are five-minute bursts built on rapid recall, and managers can spend a few minutes at a time practicing a performance or growth conversation with an AI version of one of their employees. Howson said managers logged more than 1,500 hours of that in a single quarter, and about 93% came back to do it again.
“They can do those little brief moments and they can keep trying and pushing themselves harder like you would in the gym,” Howson said.
The platform’s AI Learning Guide, which Howson called a personal professor, works differently from a typical chatbot. Instead of simply answering a question, it recommends what to learn, breaks courses into smaller pieces and tests employees on what they know.
Whatever form it takes, she said, a mind gym has to meet three conditions.
“Mind gym is a philosophy versus a product, but three things have to be true,” she said. “It needs to be effortful, it needs to be joyful, and there should be some sort of social connection.”
Managers matter more than mandates
Taking part is mostly voluntary at ServiceNow, and Howson said she opposes mandatory learning.
“I am very anti-mandatory learning,” she said. “I think anything that you’re forced to do, you’re not going to get a huge amount of benefit from.”
However, the company does require regular assessments. Managers, for example, hold an AI coach conversation twice a year that evaluates their skills. Howson said she once thought the technology would be the answer, but busy employees weren’t going to make time for it, so the company’s biggest change was to focus on managers.
That meant changing the manager’s role from pushing AI use to creating room for thinking. Employees need both capacity and permission to slow down, Howson said, and managers can supply each.
“Managers can create permission, but they can also create capacity by reducing slop, reducing meetings,” she said.
Where the habit has spread, Howson said, teams perform better and make fewer mistakes.
Her advice to other organizations follows a sequence she called work, workforce and workbench. Decide what work should change, then how to retrain people, then which technology to use.
“If you start by going, ‘We’ve bought this AI, we need to drive adoption,’ then we’re starting in the wrong place,” she said.
She likened the conditions inside an organization to the soil in a garden.
“You don’t buy expensive plants, put them in the ground, and then wonder why they fail,” Howson said. “You make sure the soil’s right, you make sure the sun and the wind and the shade and all of those things are right. We need to do the same with talent.”