Her office computer held a step-by-step search trail from the week before
A Queensland employer's investigation into a workers' compensation claim turned up a search history that read like a step-by-step fraud playbook.
In a decision handed down on November 18, 2026, the Industrial Court of Queensland ordered a former employee to pay her employer's legal costs at 1.5 times the standard scale after finding the worker had likely "investigated ways in which she could provoke [her employer] into an argument and then claim workers' compensation."
The case began in early 2021. The worker had originally been employed by heavy haulage company RW & G Johnston Pty Ltd in a data entry role. She left in late 2019, then returned in February 2020 in a more senior position. Tensions over salary and other issues followed.
On March 9, 2021, she raised a complaint with the company's director about another staff member. The conversation became heated. She had recorded it on her mobile phone.
She then filed a claim for psychiatric injury under Queensland's Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003. WorkCover Queensland, the statutory insurer, accepted the claim. The employer sought review by the Workers' Compensation Regulator, which upheld WorkCover's decision. The employer appealed to the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission.
Then came the computer records
In preparation for the hearing, the employer's solicitor commissioned forensic investigations. A report from accounting firm Vincents found that between March 2 and March 8, 2021 - the week before the workplace incident - the following searches had been conducted on the worker's office computer:
"framing boss for work compensation" (Google search); "Claim process" (WorkSafe Queensland website); "starting argument with boss while recording" (Google search); "can I record a meeting with my boss? Do I have to tell her that I am recording her?" (Lexology website); and "listening devices" (Google search).
Two further investigation reports from Brooksight Investigations showed conduct the court found appeared inconsistent with the worker's claimed psychiatric injuries.
These three reports were served on the Regulator on March 21, 2023, shortly before the original hearing date. The hearing was adjourned.
The claim unravelled fast
By May 31, 2023, the Regulator told WorkCover the case was hopeless and should be conceded. The Regulator withdrew from active defence. The worker was joined as a respondent at her own election and took over the fight.
It did not last. On October 5, 2023, the Commission made consent orders allowing the employer's appeal and setting aside the original decision to accept the claim. The worker's compensation claim was rejected.
Then the costs battle began. The employer applied for indemnity costs against the worker and a separate order against the Regulator. The Commission held it had no power to award costs at all - finding that neither the Industrial Relations Act 2016 nor the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 gave it jurisdiction in the circumstances.
The employer appealed to the Industrial Court.
Two different costs rules, one tribunal
The central legal question was straightforward, even if the answer was not: which set of costs rules applies when a workers' compensation appeal lands in the industrial tribunal?
Under the IR Act, the default is that each party pays their own way. Costs are only shifted where a party acted vexatiously or ran a case with no reasonable prospect of success. Under the WCR Act, costs of the hearing sit in the tribunal's discretion - and the starting point is that costs follow the event, meaning the loser typically pays.
The court held these are two separate regimes responding to different policy settings, and that the IR Act's costs provisions do not apply to workers' compensation appeals. The WCR Act is self-contained on this point. No prior decision of the Industrial Court had squarely decided the issue.
The Commission had also held that because the appeal settled before a traditional contested hearing, there were no "costs of the hearing" to award. The court disagreed. Costs of the hearing include preparation costs, the court found. Otherwise, "a party could simply abandon an appeal without consequence." The consent orders made on October 5, 2023 also constituted a "hearing" in themselves, the court held.
The search history sealed it
With jurisdiction established, the court exercised the costs discretion itself.
The court found it was "likely" that the worker "investigated ways in which she could provoke [her employer] into an argument and then claim workers' compensation" and that "that is what she did."
The worker had argued the internet searches were not hers - that some other employee must have used her computer. The court called this "an extraordinary coincidence" given the timing, and said any suggestion a third person conducted those searches without the worker's knowledge was "beyond belief."
A psychiatrist engaged by the employer's lawyers had initially reported that the worker met the criteria for major depressive disorder and that the workplace argument was a "significant causative factor." But that psychiatrist had confirmed he would revisit his diagnosis if the history the worker provided turned out to be unreliable. The court observed that psychiatrists and psychologists "must rely on self-reporting" - a limitation that cut to the heart of the worker's case once the computer evidence surfaced.
On appeal, the worker submitted a letter from a general practitioner dated August 15, 2025, stating she had been advised in September 2023 to avoid all conflict due to her mental state. The court received the letter but gave it "very little weight," noting the GP had also relied on the worker's own account.
The court described the worker's behaviour as "cynical and dishonest" and said she had "abandoned her claim in the face of damning evidence which severely damaged her credibility." It ordered costs at 1.5 times the standard professional scale, citing the complexity of the investigation work required.
The Regulator escaped a costs order entirely. The court accepted it was reasonable for the Regulator to have defended the claim initially - the worker had electronic evidence of the workplace incident and a supporting psychiatric diagnosis. Once the dishonesty became apparent, the Regulator stepped back. The court said the Regulator was "in many ways, a victim of [the worker's] dishonesty just like Johnston is."
For HR teams managing workers' compensation claims, the case is a practical reminder that forensic investigation of digital evidence can be decisive - and that employers who uncover a fabricated claim can recover their costs even when the matter settles before a full hearing.