Stock from China arrived weeks after the company cited supply shortages
A toy company dismissed its only New Zealand employee in a 21-minute video call - with no warning and no consultation.
The worker had been employed as the territory manager for Australian Toy Brands Limited (ATB) since August 2023. ATB produced and sold plush cuddly toys for children, and the worker was its sole salaried employee in the country.
On Friday, October 11, 2024, the company's director asked the worker to set up a one-on-one Google meeting for the following Monday.
That call started at 1:00 pm on October 14 and was over by 1:21 pm. The first 15 minutes were general chat about how things were going in New Zealand. In the final five minutes, the worker was told his position had been made redundant and his role would be performed from Australia.
One minute later - at 1:22 pm - the termination email landed.
The email gave the worker one month's notice. It cited "supply problems" and a "drastic decline" in sales and revenue as the reasons his role had been disestablished.
No restructuring proposal. No consultation. No discussion of alternatives. The worker described it as a fait accompli.
Then the stock started arriving
The worker's evidence, accepted by the Employment Relations Authority, painted a different picture from the company's supply-shortage justification.
A shipment of replacement stock for the New Zealand market left China on October 18, 2024 - just four days after the worker was told his position no longer existed. It was due to arrive by November 5, in time for the Christmas season.
A second shipment left China on December 13, 2024, with an estimated arrival in New Zealand on January 13, 2025. The worker produced shipping invoices to back up both claims.
He told the Authority these shipments were likely arranged well before he received his redundancy notice, meaning ATB would have known about them when it ended his employment.
A company that never showed up
ATB did not attend the investigation meeting on September 8, 2026. The Authority started the hearing 40 minutes late to give the company extra time. No one appeared.
The company had been served with all relevant documents, including by track-and-trace courier at its registered address. Its previous legal representative had withdrawn in December 2025, and ATB had been self-represented since, with its contact details being the director's email address.
ATB had lodged an initial statement in reply but never responded to the worker's amended claim. It filed no evidence and produced none of the documents the Authority had identified as relevant.
The Authority was satisfied ATB knew about the hearing and had elected not to attend.
The ruling
The Authority found the dismissal unjustified - both procedurally and substantively.
On process, ATB failed to give the worker any relevant information or an opportunity to comment before it dismissed him. That breached the good faith requirements of the Employment Relations Act 2000. The company also failed every one of the Act's four minimum procedural fairness tests.
The Authority held that this procedural failure fundamentally undermined ATB's ability to justify the redundancy. A fair process, the Authority said, is what helps an employer reach a fair decision. Without one, the substantive ground collapses too.
On substance, ATB could not justify the redundancy on stock-shortage grounds given the evidence that shipments were already on their way to New Zealand shortly after the worker's employment ended. Its failure to consult about redeployment or consider any alternatives further undermined its position.
What it cost
The worker had not found new permanent employment since his dismissal in October 2024. His annual salary had been $85,000. He sought $107,000 in lost remuneration covering the period from November 15, 2024, to the date of the hearing.
The Authority awarded three months' lost remuneration - $21,249.99 gross - on the basis that the worker's employment likely would not have continued beyond three months even if a fair restructuring process had been followed.
ATB was also ordered to pay $15,000 in distress compensation. The worker described the effect of his sudden dismissal as "devastating," citing shock, stress, financial pressure in the lead-up to Christmas 2024, and his wife having to return to the workforce.
Together with $2,250 in legal costs and a $71.55 filing fee reimbursement, ATB was ordered to pay the worker a total of $38,571.54 within 28 days.
For HR teams, the case is a plain reminder: redundancy requires a genuine process, not a five-minute conversation tacked onto the end of a video call. And when the stated reason is stock shortages, shipping records that tell a different story will not go unnoticed.