He wiped his laptop, quit and started a rival - then beat every claim

He even brought a private criminal prosecution. It didn't help

He wiped his laptop, quit and started a rival - then beat every claim

Two employees at a specialist tax firm resigned, launched a rival company within days - and then beat every claim their former employer threw at them. 

New Zealand's Employment Relations Authority ruled on November 9, 2026, that two workers at US Global Tax - a firm providing US tax compliance and advisory services to clients in New Zealand and Australia - did not breach their employment agreements or their duties of good faith when they left to start a competing business. 

The exit 

The firm's client services manager had been there since May 2018. His colleague, a senior tax specialist, since February that same year. On September 4, 2023, both resigned. 

That same day, the client services manager told the company's sole director about the plan: he and the tax specialist intended to set up a new company offering tax services. Rather than reaching for a lawyer, the director floated the idea of the new company doing contract work for US Global Tax. The next day, September 5, he sent an email waiving the restraint of trade and other-employment clauses in both workers' contracts. 

The CRM reports 

Two days later, on September 7, the director ran a report on the firm's client management system, SugarCRM. He discovered that between August 22 and September 1, the client services manager had created and deleted four reports containing client names and email addresses. The final report, created on September 1, contained 1,855 lines of data. 

The director did not raise this with either employee at the time. Negotiations over the contracting arrangement continued through September. 

On September 22, the client services manager emailed proposed terms of engagement to the director. Five days later, the director sent an email attempting to pull the waiver back, citing "duress" and "unlawful actions" that had "subsequently come to my attention." The following day, he told the client services manager US Global Tax would be taking legal action. 

The prosecution that went nowhere 

The director subsequently brought a private prosecution against the client services manager. The Auckland District Court heard the case in April and July 2026. On July 31, 2026, the Court acquitted him of the charges. 

What the Authority found 

The Authority then investigated the employer's claims across five issues: confidentiality, intellectual property, good faith, fidelity, and restraint of trade. 

On confidentiality, the client services manager said he created the reports to prepare a mail merge - a handover email directing clients to a US Global Tax colleague after his departure. He ran four versions because the first three did not reliably filter for New Zealand-based clients. 

Two emails backed up this explanation. His resignation email on September 4 referenced a prepared handover template. A follow-up on September 10 asked how clients would be told he was leaving. 

The forensic evidence is where things fell apart for the employer. Two IT expert witnesses gave evidence, but neither could establish that the final report had been attached to an email, that any email had been sent, or to whom. 

Then there was the timing. The client services manager had factory-reset his work laptop on September 1 - before the activity the employer suspected was the extraction of the report on September 4. As the Authority noted, if the employee had wanted to hide something, he would more likely have wiped the laptop after extracting the data, not before. Evidence that other departing employees had also performed factory resets went undisputed. 

The Authority accepted the employee's explanation and found no breach of the confidentiality or intellectual property clauses. 

Client diversion? Not quite 

The employer also alleged the client services manager had diverted prospective clients. The Authority examined each one. 

The picture did not support the claim. One prospective client had been referred to the new company by their own accountant. Another had tried to reach the employee at US Global Tax and been told he no longer worked there. A third was told by the employee to keep their work with US Global Tax. In one case, the employee referred a prospect to an entirely different business because his new firm did not handle New Zealand tax returns. 

The Authority found the employee had legitimate reasons for deferring enquiries - including the firm being stretched after several staff departures, and surgery he had booked for September 5. He had not provided alternative contact details to any prospective client, and there was no evidence either he or the new company benefited from the deferrals. 

Good faith - and who knew what, when 

On good faith, the Authority turned the spotlight on the employer's own conduct. The director discovered the CRM reports on September 7 but kept negotiating a contracting arrangement with both employees through September 27 - without saying a word about it. The waiver was in force the entire time the director knew about the very conduct he later called "criminal and/or fraudulent." 

The Authority found the employees' conduct was "responsive and communicative" and could not be called misleading or deceptive. 

The senior tax specialist's position was even cleaner. There was no evidence he had any involvement in generating or deleting the CRM reports, or in managing client relationships. His evidence that he did not use SugarCRM to generate reports went undisputed. 

The waiver stood 

On restraint of trade, the central question was whether the director's waiver - and his later attempt to rescind it - held up. The Authority found the waiver was "clear and unequivocal." Both employees had relied on it: they incorporated their new company, obtained professional indemnity insurance, purchased equipment, created a LinkedIn profile, and continued negotiating with US Global Tax. 

The director's claim that he granted the waiver under duress did not hold. The correspondence between the parties was cordial. And the director had not discovered any new information after granting the waiver - he already knew about the CRM reports by September 7 but waited three weeks before trying to claw it back. 

The Authority found the waiver valid and enforceable for both the restraint of trade and other-employment clauses. Every one of the employer's claims was dismissed. 

Costs were reserved, with the employees given 28 days to file on costs if the parties cannot resolve the issue between themselves. 

For HR teams, the case is a pointed reminder: what an employer knows - and when it acts on that knowledge - matters as much as what the departing employee did. A waiver granted with full awareness of the conduct later complained of is very hard to unwind. 

LATEST NEWS