She asked for a week to consider. The CEO gave her two days - then announced her replacement
Employer fires worker on sick leave after she hesitates on a demotion. The Employment Relations Authority was not impressed.
A Māori health care provider has been ordered to pay more than $27,000 after the Employment Relations Authority found it unjustifiably dismissed a worker who did not respond to a proposed new role within the employer's deadline - while she was home on certified sick leave.
The determination, issued on November 12, 2026, found that Ringa Atawhai Matatauranga Limited (RAM), a registered Māori health provider delivering Rongoā services in Northland, dismissed the worker with immediate effect after she did not provide an answer on a restructured employment agreement within the timeframe set by the company's CEO. The Authority found the process fell well short of what a fair and reasonable employer would have done.
From lead to administrator
The worker had been employed as Rongoā Lead since June 2023 on successive fixed-term agreements tied to government funding. When her second fixed-term agreement expired on December 31, 2024, neither side raised it. She kept turning up to work. She kept getting paid.
The Authority found that once the expiry date passed and employment continued uninterrupted, the worker's status had converted to that of a permanent employee. The onus to clarify, it held, sat with the employer - not the worker.
Things moved fast in March 2025. A new CEO had taken over and convened back-to-back hui on March 12 and 13 to discuss the Rongoā service. The worker was told her role and contract were up for review and renewal. By the second meeting, the conversation had shifted to creating a new administrator role that would sit below the lead position - at reduced hours and reduced pay.
On March 14, the CEO emailed the worker a draft employment agreement for the new role. It proposed cutting her hours from 40 to 30 per week and her salary from $80,000 to $54,000. It also included a 90-day trial period that had not existed in her previous agreements.
The CEO acknowledged the impact in writing, telling the worker: "I understand that this is a significant drop in both pay and hours, and I want to acknowledge how challenging this may be for you."
A deadline that kept shrinking
The worker asked for a week to seek advice. The CEO gave her two days. She asked what would happen if she did not sign. The response, as recorded in the determination, was blunt: since her previous agreement had expired, she would not be able to continue working in her current capacity because of the "highly sensitive information" she was privy to, and RAM would not seek to reinstate the previous agreement.
All of this was happening while the worker was on certified sick leave. A medical certificate recorded her as unfit for work from March 7.
Then came the pānui. On March 19 - the same day the worker's deadline expired - the CEO circulated an organisation-wide announcement naming a colleague as the new Rongoā Lead, effective the following day. The worker had not yet given her answer.
She emailed requesting a hui to discuss the proposal. The CEO responded that enough time had been given and that if she did not provide an answer by 4:30pm that day, he would "action immediate off-boarding process."
The next morning, March 20, the worker received a termination letter. She was dismissed with immediate effect for what the letter described as her "failure to respond within the appropriate time frame."
What the Authority found
The Authority found this was not conduct that could justify summary dismissal - a step normally reserved for serious misconduct, meaning behaviour that deeply impairs or destroys the basic trust essential to the employment relationship. Not responding quickly enough to a proposal that would substantially cut her pay and hours did not meet that threshold.
The Authority also found that a fair and reasonable employer would have paused the process while the worker was on sick leave, rather than pressing ahead with deadlines and announcements.
On the question of performance - RAM had argued it was experiencing performance issues with the worker, particularly around a backlog in ACC invoice processing that had reached $40,000 by March 2025 - the Authority noted that no formal performance concerns had ever been put to the worker, and no performance improvement plan had been put in place. The termination letter itself did not cite performance as the reason for dismissal.
The Authority determined the worker was both unjustifiably dismissed and unjustifiably disadvantaged.
What RAM was ordered to pay
The Authority ordered RAM to pay the worker $9,230.80 in lost wages (six weeks' pay, calculated from her $80,000 annual salary), $18,000 in compensation for humiliation, loss of dignity, and injury to feelings, and $71.56 for the filing fee.
On lost wages, the Authority accepted that the worker's mental health had been affected by the dismissal and that she did not begin seeking new employment until October 2025. However, it noted a pre-existing history of sick and compassionate leave and found the full period of unemployment could not be solely attributed to the dismissal - hence the six-week cap rather than a longer period.
The Authority found no contributing conduct by the worker and made no reduction to the remedies.
For HR teams - particularly in small organisations managing restructures without dedicated HR support - the case is a pointed reminder that the pressure to move quickly does not override the obligation to follow a fair process, and that pressing a worker for answers while they are on certified sick leave is a path to exactly this outcome.