Bus driver's 16-incident streak dooms bid to fight dismissal

16 complaints, a locked teenager, and a mediation deal that lasted two weeks

Bus driver's 16-incident streak dooms bid to fight dismissal

A bus driver who locked a 14-year-old girl on his bus and repeatedly made unwanted physical contact with a female passenger has lost his challenge against the company that sacked him.

The New Zealand Employment Relations Authority found on November 10, 2026 that Ritchies Transport Holdings Limited was justified in dismissing the driver for serious misconduct, rejecting his claim for reinstatement and financial remedies.

The driver had been behind the wheel for twenty years across his career. He was employed by Ritchies from July 2020 until his dismissal on February 26, 2025. By that point, the company had dealt with no fewer than 16 separate incidents of concerning behaviour in roughly two and a half years.

The incidents that sealed his fate happened across four days in December 2024.

A teenager locked on the bus

On December 1, 2024, the driver reached the final stop of his run. He did not check whether all passengers had left. A 14-year-old girl had not gotten off. He parked the bus on broken yellow lines, partially over a driveway entrance, and locked it with the teenager still inside.

He left for about ten minutes, visited a toilet, picked up food, and returned. He only realised the girl was there when he started driving toward his next route. Her mother, meanwhile, had called the police.

A review of CCTV footage from the same trip also revealed the driver had used his cell phone while driving, failed to stop at a stop sign, and parked illegally - despite a clear bus stop with nearby toilets sitting roughly 50 metres away.

The driver said he had skipped the required bus check because he urgently needed the toilet. The Authority noted two more convenient toilet options had been available closer to where he could have legally parked.

Unwanted contact across three days

Then came complaints from a separate female passenger about incidents on December 16, 17 and 18. She reported repeated unwanted physical contact - the driver grabbing her hand and asking for her home address.

Ritchies reviewed CCTV footage, which confirmed the physical contact across all three days. There was no audio on the footage, so the home address request could not be verified that way. But the passenger's account was clear: she said the behaviour had been going on for three weeks before she complained, that she had changed her bus route to avoid the driver, and that she asked for her identity be kept from him because she did "not know what he's capable of."

The driver declined to comment on the appropriateness of his contact on December 16. For December 17, his counsel submitted that the driver was "very clear now that interaction with passenger of the nature which has led to this present complaint, simply cannot happen again and he is very sorry that it did despite the prior assurance."

He also suggested the CCTV showed the interactions were amicable. The Authority found that did not align with the passenger's account.

A long paper trail

The December incidents were far from the first time Ritchies had raised concerns.

In October 2023, a disciplinary meeting addressed three earlier complaints: the driver had asked a passenger's young daughter for her phone number and suggested visiting the girl at home to see her cuddly toys; he had kissed a young female passenger's hand and said he would phone her during the holidays; and he had pulled a female passenger close by her arm and told her she did not have to pay her fare.

The driver accepted he should not be touching passengers, particularly young females. Ritchies chose not to take further action after he gave assurances it would not happen again.

In late 2023, Ritchies issued four separate "please explain" requests - one for giving flowers to a female passenger and trying to catch her hand, and three for failing to stop for passengers on his route.

In early 2024, the driver received a written warning after he changed lanes without indicating, hit another car, allegedly refused to exchange details, failed to report the accident, and unloaded school students onto a live traffic lane.

By mid-2024, the warnings escalated. In May, he accelerated before an elderly female passenger was seated, causing her to fall, hit her head and cut her leg. He did not report the incident. In August, rough braking caused an elderly couple to hit their heads on the seat in front of them, injuring the husband's finger. Again, no incident report.

A final written warning was issued on September 6, 2024 after the driver was found to have driven the wrong way down a road towards opposing traffic - conduct Ritchies classified as serious misconduct. The company could have dismissed him then. It chose not to.

Two weeks after mediation

Just over two months later, the parties attended mediation. On November 19, 2024, they signed a Memorandum of Understanding. The driver had said he was stressed by the volume of "please explain" letters. Ritchies agreed to try raising concerns informally first. The agreement also recorded that the driver had been provided with a copy of the Code of Conduct and was expected to comply with it.

The December incidents began roughly two to three weeks later.

The Authority's finding

The driver accepted that Ritchies had followed a fair process. He did not dispute that the conduct had occurred. His argument was narrow: the conduct was not serious enough to warrant dismissal, and dismissal fell outside the range of reasonable responses.

The Authority disagreed on both counts.

Each of the December incidents was independently capable of amounting to serious misconduct, the Authority found. The conduct breached the driver's obligations under driving legislation, the Code of Conduct, his position description, and the Bus Drivers' Manual - which stated drivers must "Avoid all physical contact. Maintain 1 metre separation" from passengers.

On whether dismissal was proportionate, the Authority pointed to the full employment history. Every measure short of dismissal had already been tried. Informal counselling, written warnings, a final written warning, and mediation had all failed to produce lasting change. The driver's own counsel had submitted, in the final round of representations before dismissal, a "frank acknowledgement of the conduct alleged and an assertion that this was 'really the last time.'"

That was not enough. There was no evidence the driver would not engage in the same or similar conduct if given another chance. The options short of dismissal had been exhausted.

For HR teams managing long-tenure employees through progressive discipline, the case is a straightforward illustration: patience and documentation through the warning process can make a dismissal decision virtually unassailable - but only when each step is recorded and the employee is given a genuine opportunity to respond.

LATEST NEWS