Farm worker’s ‘gut instinct’ on safety costs job but nets payout

Police, a fibreglass pole and a Teams call from the local library

Farm worker’s ‘gut instinct’ on safety costs job but nets payout

A dairy farm worker who called health and safety a matter of “gut instinct” lost his job - but still pocketed $11,400. 

The Employment Court of New Zealand ruled on November 9 that Pāmu - the trading name of state-owned Landcorp Farming - justifiably dismissed the seasonal head calf rearer for serious misconduct. But the court also found the company failed to properly investigate his bullying complaints and mishandled his suspension. 

Eleven days and a letter of expectations 

The worker started at Pāmu’s Pinta Dairy Unit in July 2023. Within 11 days, his farm manager issued a letter of expectations over failures to wear a seatbelt, helmet and hi-vis vest while operating a side-by-side vehicle. 

The letter was blunt: “Safety is non-negotiable at Pāmu.” 

It did not stick. On August 14, the farm manager spotted the worker driving without a helmet. The next day, he was photographed without his hi-vis vest. When stood down on the spot, the worker refused to leave. “I’ll see you in court,” he said. Police were eventually called. By the time they arrived, he had finished his tasks and gone. 

‘A matter of gut instinct’ 

At the disciplinary meeting - held via Microsoft Teams because Pāmu said it felt unsafe meeting in person - the worker stated that safety “can be a matter of gut instinct.” 

The court found that position untenable. Agriculture accounts for around 25 percent of New Zealand’s acute work-related fatalities and serious injuries while making up just six percent of the workforce. The worker’s admitted breaches and “continued minimisation of risk” meant dismissal was within the range open to a fair and reasonable employer. 

Where Pāmu came unstuck 

But the company’s process drew sharp criticism on two fronts. 

The farm manager had already decided to stand the worker down before asking how he felt about it - what the court called “effectively window dressing.” There was no immediate danger. The safety concerns related to the previous day. 

The bullying response fared no better. The worker had raised complaints at a formal meeting and again during the disciplinary process, presenting a WhatsApp message from the farm manager written entirely in capital letters in a group chat visible to his direct reports. Each time, the concerns were brushed aside. The head of farming simply asked the managers what they had done and accepted their answer. No further inquiry followed. 

“The issues having been raised, it was up to the employer to take them seriously and make further inquiries,” the court held. 

Compensation came to $11,400 - $6,000 for each upheld grievance, with a 10 percent reduction on the suspension award for the worker’s own conduct during the standdown. No reduction applied to the bullying failure; the court held the worker bore no responsibility for the company’s failure to investigate. 

For HR teams in safety-sensitive industries, the message is plain: getting the dismissal right does not cover for cutting corners on suspension or tuning out internal complaints running alongside. 

LATEST NEWS