He gave up $40K to keep two colleagues employed - then got fired
A principal accountant who cut his own pay to save two colleagues from redundancy has lost his right to challenge his dismissal.
The Fair Work Commission dismissed the unfair dismissal application on November 12, 2026, finding the worker's annual earnings at the time he was fired exceeded the high income threshold - the salary cap above which employees not covered by an award or enterprise agreement cannot bring an unfair dismissal claim.
The worker was the principal accountant at Medcraft Cooper & Associates, a Melbourne-based accounting practice within a group of firms. He ran the practice day-to-day, managed the staff, and dealt with clients.
The trouble started with cash flow
In mid-2024, the firm's two directors decided the practice was overstaffed for its revenue and told the worker to make two administrative employees redundant. He did not want to do that.
Instead, in August 2024, he proposed an alternative: he would drop his own salary from $150,000 to $110,000 until the firm's finances improved. One director later acknowledged the worker wanted to "keep the team together."
The directors agreed. From September 1, 2024, the worker was paid at the reduced rate.
The deal, as recorded in emails between the parties, was that the worker would "recoup" the shortfall once the firm had onboarded major new clients. His August 23, 2024 email put it plainly: he would "take a reduced pay for now and recover after the fact." His September 3 email was more specific: "I am reducing my salary by 40K but will recoup once major clients onboarding complete."
No formal written agreement was drawn up. The email chain between August and September 2024 was the only written record.
Then came the repayment plan
By March 2025, the firm was starting to show a monthly profit on its books. The worker met with the two directors at a cafe in Brighton. He said they agreed he would be paid at a rate of $193,300 per year for 43 weeks starting July 1, 2025. That figure was calculated to cover both his $150,000 base salary and the amount he had gone without during the pay cut period from September 2024 to June 2025. After the 43 weeks, his pay would drop back to $150,000.
The directors either denied or could not recall that conversation. One said he understood any increase to be permanent. The other said the worker had mentioned wanting a salary of $200,000, and he was "agreeable" to an increase.
The Commission preferred the worker's account. Neither director could explain how the "odd" figure of $193,300 was arrived at. No written record supported a permanent increase to that amount. And the firm's practice manager had set a calendar reminder for March 9, 2026 to reduce the worker's pay back down - which made no sense if the increase was permanent.
On September 25, 2025, the firm dismissed the worker.
The $10,200 that made the difference
When the worker applied for an unfair dismissal remedy, the firm objected on a threshold ground. He was not covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement, so his eligibility depended on whether his annual earnings fell below $183,100 - the high income threshold for the 2025-26 financial year.
The firm said his earnings were $193,300. The worker said his real salary was $150,000 and the difference was simply repayment of what he was owed.
The Commission found that the entire weekly payment of $3,717.31 - equivalent to $193,300 per year - counted as "wages" under section 332 of the Fair Work Act. The payments were made on a regular cycle for work performed, appeared on payslips as the worker's salary, and were paid directly to him. The temporary nature of the arrangement did not change what the payments were at the time they were made.
The worker's legal team argued the repayment portion was a "reimbursement" and should be excluded from earnings. The Commission rejected that too. Under the Act, a reimbursement means repayment of an expense incurred on behalf of the employer - like out-of-pocket costs for work travel. The salary shortfall was not an expense the worker had incurred. It was a debt the firm owed him, which is a different thing entirely.
"I do not regard the weekly payments made after 1 July 2025 as rectification of an underpayment and 'back pay' as such," the decision stated. The Commission noted that the worker had proposed the salary reduction himself, distinguishing the arrangement from a situation where an employer had failed to pay what was owed.
The worker's counsel raised a broader concern: that treating these payments as wages could mean any employee who received back-pay after a genuine underpayment might be pushed above the threshold. The Commission noted this scenario was "very unlikely" in practice, because employees covered by awards or enterprise agreements are not subject to the high income threshold at all.
With annual earnings of $193,300 at the time of dismissal, the worker exceeded the $183,100 threshold by just over $10,000. The Commission found he was not protected from unfair dismissal and dismissed the application.
The decision noted the temporary pay arrangement was genuine and "not some form of sham arrangement designed to defeat an employee's access to the unfair dismissal jurisdiction."
For HR teams managing temporary salary reductions or back-pay arrangements, the practical takeaway is direct: how a recoupment deal is structured on paper can determine whether a dismissed employee has access to the unfair dismissal system at all.