She earns HK$36,850 a month and has HK$2,000 to spare
An enrolled nurse who was injured on the job now has 28 days to find HK$300,000 - or her appeal gets thrown out.
Hong Kong's Court of Appeal handed down the order on November 17, 2026, in a workers' compensation dispute against the Hospital Authority that turns on a question every HR team managing injury claims will recognise: when a workplace accident aggravates a pre-existing condition, how far does the employer's liability stretch?
The nurse was hurt in an accident at work on January 5, 2020. She took two days of sick leave straight away. Months later, she went on certified sick leave again - this time from April 28, 2020 through June 27, 2021 - which she attributed to the same injury.
The District Court was not convinced. In an August 2024 judgment, the court awarded her just HK$1,228, covering only those first two days. The court found she had not established any loss of earning capacity connected to the accident, and could not show that her medical expenses from late April 2020 onward were caused by the original workplace injury.
The nurse appealed.
Her case leaned heavily on a 2006 Court of Final Appeal decision - LKK Trans Ltd v Wong Hoi Chung - which established that an injured worker is entitled to full compensation for temporary incapacity so long as the workplace injury was a cause of that incapacity, even if not the sole cause.
The Court of Appeal had already found her appeal "reasonably arguable" when it granted her an extension of time to file. But that was a lower bar than what came next.
The Hospital Authority applied for security for costs - essentially asking the court to make the nurse put up HK$716,600 in cash before the appeal could proceed. The argument: she did not have the financial resources to cover the Hospital Authority's costs if she lost.
The nurse pushed back. She told the court she lives in public housing. She earns roughly HK$36,850 a month but has only HK$1,000 to HK$2,000 left after rent, family support, and living expenses. She was pregnant. Her employment contract was due to expire on August 31, 2026. Her husband earns a modest income. She had already deposited HK$101,073 with the Legal Aid Department.
She was now representing herself.
The court accepted that a large security order would probably stifle the appeal. But it was not persuaded the appeal's merits were strong enough to avoid a security order entirely.
The Hospital Authority's counsel argued - with what the court called "considerable force" - that whether the workplace accident remained a substantially contributing cause of the nurse's incapacity was a question of fact, not law. The court also noted that the LKK principle may apply only to permanent incapacity under section 9 of the Employees' Compensation Ordinance, not temporary incapacity under section 10 - a distinction that could narrow its reach considerably.
The court further observed that the nurse's claims about her finances were "unsupported by financial statements or records," and that she had not accounted for periodic payments totalling over HK$159,000 she had already received in connection with the accident.
The result was a split-the-difference order. Security was set at HK$300,000 - less than half what the Hospital Authority sought, but a hefty sum for someone with disposable income in the low four figures. She has 28 days to pay it into court. If she does not, the appeal is automatically dismissed. All proceedings are stayed in the meantime.
The costs of the security application itself were ordered against the nurse, to be assessed separately.
The underlying question the appeal raises - how causation works when a workplace injury collides with a pre-existing condition - remains unresolved. The court acknowledged it is "a recurring question of general public importance" affecting many employees in Hong Kong who suffer work-related injuries complicated by existing health conditions.
For HR teams handling workplace injury claims, the unresolved question at the heart of this case matters: whether a workplace accident needs to be the primary driver of an employee's incapacity or merely a contributing factor can be the difference between paying for two days and paying for fourteen months.