$8.8M 'non-functional' software: Singapore court hits resellers with fraud finding

Customers got cash instead of software - and a cleaner signed the paperwork at a coffee shop

$8.8M 'non-functional' software: Singapore court hits resellers with fraud finding

A leasing company that paid $8,819,000 for enterprise resource planning software has won its fraud case on appeal after a Singapore appellate court found the product was never fit for use. 

The November 17 decision in GC Lease Singapore Pte Ltd v Genvio Consultancy Pte Ltd and others [2026] SGHC(A) 28 overturned a lower court ruling that had largely dismissed the leasing company's claims. 

The arrangement worked like this. GC Lease, a Singapore-incorporated company in the business of leasing office equipment and software, agreed to finance customers who wanted to lease enterprise resource planning software. The software was purportedly developed by a company called Fonbell Solution and sold through three resellers - Genvio Consultancy, Purifico Solutions, and Ace Elite Consultancy - each operated by a sole director-shareholder. 

Between August 2017 and January 2019, GC Lease purchased 102 software licences from Fonbell and the resellers, then leased them on a back-to-back basis to 102 customers the resellers had introduced. The software was marketed as an office management solution with billing management, inventory management, and human resources and payroll modules. 

Then the defaults started rolling in. By mid-January 2019, 25 customers had stopped paying. Eventually, 97 of the 102 customers defaulted. Only five ever paid in full. 

The software was 'work-in-progress' 

The court accepted evidence from a software expert who compared the product's actual functionality against the features described in the resellers' invoices. His conclusion was blunt: the software was "substantially different from the system described in the [Fonbell Solution] User Manual and the system as implied in the Reseller Invoice," was "still a work-in-progress and not ready for actual production use," and was "showing testing/debugging information, broken functionality and system processing errors with system error messages." 

Features listed in the invoices - including human resources and payroll functions such as job titles, pay grades, equal employment opportunity identification, leave application, reimbursement and claims - were missing entirely. 

The lower court had treated this evidence as speaking to "best in class" software standards rather than basic functionality. The appellate court disagreed. The question was not whether the software could perform "some rudimentary tasks," the court held, but whether it could "fully discharge the functions that were attributed to it." Software riddled with errors and bugs that could not fully accomplish its tasks "cannot truly be said to be functional." 

No trace of software among 50 customers 

Liquidators of approximately 50 of the customer companies told the court they found no evidence the software had ever been installed. Officers of those companies could not explain how the software was accessed or used, and could not provide any meaningful information about it. 

The appellate court found the lower court erred in dismissing this evidence. These were customers who had purportedly leased the software "for substantial sums amounting to thousands of dollars," the court noted. If the software had genuinely been installed and used, "one would reasonably expect there to be some trace of that." 

There was also no evidence that Fonbell or its related company Ofywork had the infrastructure to host, maintain, or support the cloud-based software. The developer behind the software told the court he had engaged an Indian service provider for maintenance, but produced no engagement letter, agreement, or documentary evidence of the arrangement. Fonbell's own liquidator testified there was "not a single piece of documentary evidence" that the company had developed a functional software product. 

Cash, not software 

Five customers called as witnesses told a different story about what the transactions were actually for. 

One testified he met a reseller representative "fully for the loan only" and was to receive $60,000 and repay $120,000 over five years. WhatsApp messages between that representative and the customer referred to the first instalment as "the first month loan." After the company was taken over, the messages read: "Then we can proceed with the loan" and "Finally can get it through." 

Another customer's representative testified the company needed funds and was told it could obtain a loan by buying the software. She "never saw or used the software." A third witness was a company director who worked as a cleaner and could not read English. He signed the relevant documents at a coffee shop without knowing what they were for and was not shown any software. 

Backdated records and lost phones 

Corporate records revealed a pattern. Directors' appointments and share transfers were backdated by two to four years shortly before the relevant transactions for nine of one reseller's 11 customers. Similar backdated lodgements appeared across 33 of Genvio's 47 customers and 21 of Purifico's 24 customers. 

The resellers' representatives claimed they had paid large sums in cash to "introducers" who sourced customers for them. One accepted that approximately $540,000 per month was paid in cash to introducers over a three-month period between November 2018 and January 2019. None of the payments were documented. No receipts were signed. And the representatives could not produce WhatsApp communications with their introducers. Each claimed to have changed their phone and lost access to the messages. 

The court found these explanations "just too convenient." One representative's WhatsApp messages with a customer had in fact survived - because the customer had exhibited them in separate bankruptcy proceedings. 

The court also noted that the representatives' trial evidence about payments to introducers directly contradicted their own pleadings, which had stated that all payments went to Fonbell's director. 

What the court found 

The appellate court found all four representations made by the resellers were false and made dishonestly: that the software worked, that the resellers were running a genuine business, that the customers were genuine, and that the software had been delivered and installed. 

On the conspiracy claim, the court held the evidence "broadly supports the inference that there was a combination" between the software developer, the representatives, and others to procure payments from GC Lease through dishonest representations. The non-functionality of the software was "the thread that knits everything together." 

The court also found Genvio breached Singapore's Sale of Goods Act - the software did not match its description and was not of satisfactory quality. 

GC Lease was awarded the full $8,819,000 in damages against the respondents, who are each liable for the entire amount. The sum is to be reduced by any amounts recovered from customers. 

What this means for HR teams 

For HR professionals involved in software procurement, the case is a pointed reminder that due diligence on enterprise resource planning vendors needs to go beyond a sales demonstration. The software at the centre of this scheme had HR and payroll modules on its invoices that simply did not exist in the product - and a financing company that relied on reseller assurances without independently verifying delivery paid $8.8 million for the gap. 

LATEST NEWS