Four workers say they paid $40,000 each in cash just to get hired
Four migrant workers just cleared a major hurdle in their fight against a labour hire director they say made them pay $40,000 each for the privilege of a job.
The Employment Court of New Zealand dismissed two preliminary applications on November 16 that would have narrowed or derailed the workers' claims against the sole director of Khanna Enterprises Ltd, a now-liquidated labour hire company and accredited employer with Immigration New Zealand. The director had asked the court to throw out parts of the claim and to order the workers to rewrite their pleading with more detail. He lost on both counts.
The workers, all originally from India, allege they were each promised a 36-month work visa, an hourly rate of $29.70 and a minimum of 40 hours' pay per week. The price of entry, according to the second amended statement of claim, was a cash payment of 20 lakh rupees - approximately $40,000 NZD - handed to the director's parents.
What they say they got was something else entirely.
The claim alleges that when work hours fell below 40, they were paid only for the hours actually worked. When hours exceeded 40, they were still paid for 40. Public holiday entitlements, paid sick leave and annual holidays were all allegedly denied.
The workers were later told their employment had been transferred to another company, SAS Recruitment Ltd, whose director had links to both the first company and its director. That company was subsequently removed from the Companies Register in 2024. Khanna Enterprises itself went into liquidation in March 2025.
The workers raised personal grievances in late 2023 and resigned in November of that year, alleging constructive dismissal from what the claim describes as an exploitative situation.
Two applications, both dismissed
The director's first application asked the court to strike out parts of the claim - essentially, to rule that certain allegations were so weak they should not proceed to trial. His main argument: the allegation that he sought and obtained an unlawful premium from the workers was untenable because police in India had investigated and not brought criminal charges.
The court was unpersuaded. Whether an unlawful premium was obtained is a question for the Employment Court, not the Indian police, the judgment noted. At the strike-out stage, the facts as alleged are assumed to be true - and on that basis, the court had "no difficulty concluding" the claims were capable of supporting the case.
The director also argued that the workers needed to first obtain the court's permission before pursuing a personal liability claim against him under section 142Y of the Employment Relations Act 2000 - the provision that allows employees to go after individuals involved in breaches of minimum employment standards. The court rejected that too, citing its earlier decision in Kongbang v Lotus Touch Ltd, which held that no separate leave application is required. Reading in a distinct two-step process, the court found, would be "overly procedurally complicated and run counter to the remedial underpinnings of this part of the Act."
A further argument - that the personal grievances were not validly raised within the statutory 90-day window - also fell short. The claim sets out a series of communications the workers say constituted the raising of their grievances, and at the strike-out stage, those pleadings must be accepted as true.
Particulars deemed sufficient
The second application asked the court to order the workers to file a more detailed version of their claim. The director challenged several paragraphs, arguing they did not clearly set out the case he had to meet.
The court disagreed on every point. The allegations around premium payments, underpayment and constructive dismissal were sufficiently clear. The court noted it was "not uncommon" for workers not to set out precisely what hours they worked at the pleading stage, as that detail is generally dealt with as evidence at the hearing itself.
Both applications were dismissed. The workers were awarded costs, with the amount to be determined.
For HR teams managing labour hire arrangements and migrant worker onboarding, the case puts a practical question on the table: when a company goes into liquidation, section 142Y means the director behind it may still be personally on the hook - and no separate court permission is needed to bring that claim.