Flatter isn't always better: The case for workplace hierarchies

As organizations shed management layers, a Stanford professor argues that the answer isn't fewer hierarchies, but healthier ones

Flatter isn't always better: The case for workplace hierarchies

Every organization has a hierarchy, whether it's drawn on an org chart or takes shape informally among colleagues. When it works, people know where they stand and how to rise through the ranks. When it doesn't, the problems show up in turnover, wellbeing and team performance.

Nir Halevy, a professor of organizational behavior at Stanford Graduate School of Business in California, argues in his new book, Level Up: Why Hierarchies Are Broken and How to Fix Them, that many hierarchies aren't working. In an interview with HRD America, he described what he calls the syndrome of the broken hierarchy.

"We have a lot of broken hierarchies that tend to be ultra-competitive, unjust, and unstable," Halevy said. "These are three interrelated symptoms. When you have all of them together, you get the syndrome of the broken hierarchy, which really hurts not just individual wellbeing in terms of employee physical and mental health, but also team functioning as well as organizational success."

Where hierarchies go wrong

Halevy said broken hierarchies take a toll on retention and employee wellbeing. He cited a study of nurses who developed insomnia after changes to their compensation structure effectively demoted them; however, insomnia levels dropped when supervisors were trained to provide social support.

Halevy said each of the three symptoms he described has its own warning signs. Ultra-competitiveness can look like hoarding information or sabotaging a colleague's performance. Signs of injustice include decisions made without transparent rationales, while surprising demotions and promotions point to instability. His book includes quizzes readers can use to diagnose their own workplaces.

"Based on data I collected in May of 2026 using these quizzes," he said, "based on samples that are mirroring census data in the U.K. and the U.S., I would say that 1 in 4 employees is currently working in a broken hierarchy."

Thinning out management layers is one way companies have reshaped their hierarchies, and HRD America has reported that flattening can carry a steep human cost. Gallup's 2026 State of the Global Workplace report found that global manager engagement fell to 22% in 2025, down from 31% in 2022, and suggested flattening may be a factor in South Asia's decline. Asked about the move toward flatter organizations, Halevy said such structures are difficult to sustain over time.

"I will say that even organizations that pretend to be flat are not really flat," he said. "They're not really flat because they have informal hierarchies that emerge in them."

He pointed to Valve, which has claimed to be boss-free since 1996 but pays people differently. Halevy said employees care whether they earn less or more than peers doing similar jobs.

A three-part framework for healthier hierarchies

Halevy's solution is a framework he calls CPR, short for common value, pluralism and relatedness. Common value means a hierarchy that serves everyone, not just those at the top. Pluralism means offering several ways to rise.

"I want a hierarchy that offers multiple pathways to contributing, thriving, ascending, and leading," Halevy said. "That's really important. That's how you keep talent in the organization by creating a jungle gym instead of a ladder where people have to step on each other on their way to the top."

Relatedness means pulling people together rather than pitting them against each other. He gave the example of a manager hiring two summer interns. The manager could tell them only one will be kept on for the long term, so the best person gets the spot. Or the manager could say both can stay if they bring in enough new accounts and budgets to create more work for the team.

"Managers can actually shape what we measure in organizations, how we reward certain behaviors," he said. "People are familiar with the concept of meritocracy, but we can supplement it with a virtuocracy."

He explained that the idea is to measure and reward the virtues an organization values when deciding who to recruit, keep and promote.

He also pointed to David Hallberg, artistic director of The Australian Ballet, who promoted two dancers to the company's highest rank, principal artist, after a performance of Swan Lake at the Sydney Opera House. He made the announcement from the stage and explained the criteria behind his decision to the audience of 1,400 people.

"We're achieving C and P and R all at once," Halevy said. "We're showing that we can share leadership. We're showing that we're accountable to the criteria based on which we're promoting."

Where HR comes in

Halevy's advice for HR leaders starts with parallel hierarchies. In healthcare, where HRD America has reported on workers who keep showing up despite burnout, he said administrators, nurses and physicians aren't compared on the same metric. He said HR can build the same approach by developing tools that evaluate different kinds of contributors on different dimensions, which helps people advance on their own terms.

Halevy also described what he calls the power without status effect. Some roles, such as those in charge of budgets or reimbursements, carry real power but don't earn much respect from colleagues. He said his research, including lab studies and work with federal government leaders and managers, found that combination to be particularly toxic.

"People in these roles, because they feel underappreciated and undervalued, tend to act on their power that they have to demean and abuse others and start dysfunctional interpersonal conflicts," Halevy said.

"We hear a lot about empowerment, not enough about elevating the status of certain role holders," he added.

HR professionals, he said, are the best people to identify those roles and ask how to recognize the people in them. An iHire survey HRD America covered found that nearly eight in 10 respondents named poor leadership or management as the top reason for a toxic workplace.

Halevy said leaders often assume an existing hierarchy is there for a reason, so they don't question it. Getting CEOs and top management teams to act, he said, starts with their pain points.

"If recruiting and retention are really difficult right now, maybe we can help with that by fixing the broken hierarchy," he said.

He added that organizations already invest heavily in attracting, selecting, onboarding and retaining people, and that improving the hierarchy can reduce friction in each of those areas.

"The question I'm posing to leaders, to the managers that I'm meeting, is, do you believe your team or organization can do better?" Halevy said.

LATEST NEWS