Government urged to restore pay equity claims
New Zealand's High Court has found that the government's amended pay equity rules breached women's rights, in a ruling that unions hailed as a "historic decision."
Justice Paul Radich issued a declaration on 19 November stating that the 2025 amendments to the country's Equal Pay Act were "inconsistent" with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act.
"I make a declaration that the Equal Pay Act 1972, as amended by the Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025, is inconsistent with the… Bill of Rights Act to be free from discrimination on the ground of sex," Radich said.
Radich said the declaration will recognise the rights of the women who work within undervalued female-dominated workforces.
"A declaration vindicates their positions. They deserve to have the importance of the right, and the fact of its breach, is recognised by the Court," the judge added.
Amended equal pay rules
New Zealand's amendments to the Equal Pay Act drew strong pushback from unions amid a rushed passing in 2025, as well as the cancellation of 33 active pay equity claims at the time.
Under the controversial legislation, the government will require clear evidence to ensure that there are reasonable grounds to believe that work is historically and currently undervalued.
It also raises the threshold for deciding if a job is predominantly performed by females from 60% to 70%. It also requires that this should be the case for at least 10 consecutive years.
Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Brooke van Velden previously defended the amendments, saying the previous version of the legislation was "not working as intended."
"Claims have been able to progress without strong evidence of undervaluation and there have been very broad claims where it is difficult to tell whether differences in pay are due to sex-based discrimination or other factors," the minister said.
The Crown also told the High Court that the overarching objective of the legislation was the long-term sustainability of the pay equity framework.
But Radich said that there is "nothing tangible" to support the proposition that the previous system was not working as it should.
"The documents, viewed as a whole, show that the main driver was fiscal, that the amendments stemmed from that driver and that the proposed amendments then led to a public explanation that a pay equity process was being maintained, but that it needed to be more robust," the judge added.
Unions welcome declaration
The challenge to the government's Equal Pay Act amendments was brought forward by five unions, namely the New Zealand Nurses Organisation (NZNO), the Public Service Association (PSA), the New Zealand Post-Primary Teachers' Association, the New Zealand Tertiary Education Union, and the New Zealand Educational Institute.
The PSA in a statement welcomed the High Court's ruling as a "historic decision."
"The Court has done what Parliament should have done, listened fairly to women workers about their need for pay equity and upheld their fundamental rights but the fight is not over," said PSA national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons in a statement.
Fitzsimons added that the court confirmed what women knew all along, which is that pay equity is a fundamental right and must be upheld.
"The next Government must now do the right thing by women and restore real pay equity legislation, and the pay equity claims as a priority," she said.
The NZNO echoed the call to restore the cancelled pay equity claims.
"The next government must change the law and restore the 33 cancelled pay equity claims covering 180,000 workers, most of them women, in the first 100 days in office," said Lisa Marriner, NZNO delegate and aged care healthcare assistant, in a statement.
What happens next?
The High Court's decision does not revoke the law, but it means the Attorney-General needs to report the breach to Parliament, with the government needing to formally respond.
The Crown also has the option to appeal the case, but the government is still considering its next move, according to van Velden.
"The Crown needs to consider whether to appeal, so that limits what I or any government minister can say. This Government committed to a well-functioning pay equity regime. We didn't think the previous legislative regime got the settings right," van Velden said as quoted by 1News.
"Given there is the possibility of appeal and government is operating in a caretaker capacity, I do not intend to comment further."