The 'not the right fit' excuse didn't survive the witness box
A franchise business dismissed a new employee after barely a day on the job - and an Australian court has found the real reason was that he took carer's leave to look after his sick child.
The Federal Circuit and Family Court handed down its decision on November 17, 2026, in a general protections case that turned on what actually motivated the employer to end the worker's employment during his first week.
The worker had been hired as a franchise onboarding consultant at The Local Guys - Services Pty Ltd, an Adelaide-based franchise business offering test and tagging, pest control, cleaning and carpet cleaning franchises across Australia and New Zealand. He accepted the role on a full-time permanent basis at $65,000 a year, starting June 2, 2025.
The job came with a complication that turned out to matter: the company's franchise team leader had flagged concerns after the worker's trial role play. She found him "too salesy" and "a little up himself," according to a text message she sent the operations manager at the time. But the company's CEO and director overruled her. His gut feeling, she wrote in that same text, was that the new hire "was the one."
One day that changed everything
The worker's first official day was uneventful. He completed self-directed online training modules at his desk. He had no contact with clients. He was invited into an internal staff chat group and, by all accounts from the evidence, got along fine with colleagues.
Then, mid-afternoon, his daughter's after-school care called. The child was unwell and needed collecting. The child's mother was unavailable. He got approval from the operations manager to leave early at around 3.30 pm. "That's okay, we can pick up tomorrow, go and get your daughter," she told him, according to the court's findings.
The next morning, the daughter was still too sick for school and no alternative carer was available. The worker texted in at 7.39 am, apologised, offered a carer's certificate, and confirmed he expected to return the following day. His manager's reply was warm: "No worries, thanks for letting me know. I hope she's okay!"
By Wednesday morning, the child's condition had worsened. The worker texted again, explained the situation, and offered a carer's certificate for two consecutive days off. This time, there was no friendly reply. The operations manager spoke to the CEO, who directed her to call the worker and terminate his employment.
"Not the right fit" - or something else entirely
The court heard that when the worker pushed back during the termination call, saying he believed the dismissal was because of his daughter, the operations manager linked his two-day absence to an assessment that he was "not a good fit." The employer later formalised that explanation in writing: "it became clear early on that the role was not the right fit."
But the court did not buy it.
The decision found the CEO was "not a reliable witness," describing him as "evasive, defensive and lacking in candour." The court found it "glaringly improbable" that the CEO had decided on the worker's first day to let him go for cultural-fit reasons - particularly given the enthusiasm with which he had recruited him over his team leader's objections.
The court characterised the employer's explanation as a "post hoc rationalisation" and found the evidence to be a "fabrication," constructed only after it became clear the worker would not quietly accept his dismissal.
Criticisms that the worker had taken too many breaks and posted an off-colour joke in the staff chat group were found to have been "exaggerated and fabricated to justify the termination." The court noted the breaks were never raised with the worker, and the joke had drawn laughing emojis and a playful GIF from the operations manager herself.
Two other company witnesses - the operations manager and the team leader - had been placed in an "invidious position," the court found, effectively pushed to support the CEO's version of events, though the court's impression was that "each was disinclined to lie."
An onus the employer could not shift
Under the Fair Work Act, when a worker claims they were sacked for exercising a protected right, the burden falls on the employer to prove otherwise. That provision - section 361 - meant The Local Guys and its CEO had to show the dismissal was not because of the carer's leave. The court found they failed.
The worker had a clear right to unpaid carer's leave from day one. That right sits in the National Employment Standards and does not depend on how long someone has been in the job or whether they are on probation. His daughter's illness was a qualifying reason under the Act, and notice was given promptly each morning.
The court held that the real reason for the dismissal was the worker's decision to exercise that right. It was, the decision found, "an irresistible conclusion that the only operative factor exercising [the CEO's] mind after 2 June was Mr White's unexpected absence from the workplace."
What it cost
The court ordered $12,500 for direct economic loss and $5,000 for non-economic loss - a total of $17,500 in compensation, to be paid by the company and its CEO personally.
The economic loss figure was tempered by what the court called an exercise in guessing at an alternate reality: perhaps the worker would have thrived after probation, or perhaps a "cliquey workplace" would have pushed him out regardless. He was without a viable income for a period the court described as around eight months before securing a new role at a comparable salary.
The non-economic loss was described as "modest." The court noted the worker had shown "tenacity and firmness of purpose" in pursuing his claim and getting back on his feet - and that the greatest salve to his feelings was likely the outcome of the case itself.
The company also admitted failing to provide pay slips within the required timeframe and failing to issue a Fair Work Information Statement at the start of employment. The CEO was found personally liable under section 550 of the Act - a provision that makes a person who aids, procures or is knowingly concerned in a company's breach equally responsible for it.
A separate claim that the employer made a deliberately false or misleading statement about the worker's rights - by conditioning his notice pay on him agreeing the "matter is now closed" - was dismissed. The court found the attempt was more "wishful thinking" than deliberate misrepresentation, and the worker had not been misled.
A penalty hearing has been set for December 17, 2026, where both the company and the CEO face potential civil penalties. The maximum for each contravention is 60 penalty units per individual - and five times that for the corporate employer.
For HR teams, the case is a pointed reminder that carer's leave protections apply from day one, probation or not - and that a "not the right fit" explanation assembled after the fact will not survive a credibility contest in court