You don’t have to be a transformational leader

You can’t scroll through a leadership blog without coming across the term ‘transformational’. But is that kind of management all it’s cracked up to be?

You don’t have to be a transformational leader
Mention transformational leadership and the celebrated public speakers of the generations tend to come up as examples. Richard Branson, Barack Obama, Steve Jobs. Charismatic, fit men with gravitas, melodious voices, and faces that strike the perfect balance of good-looking-but-not-too-good-looking, somewhere between George Clooney and your barista.

It’s a personality type that most people will never fit, but managers have been striving towards those ideals since the term was first coined in the 1970s. And finally, for those who feel they might never get there, there’s evidence that leadership doesn’t have to be quite so dramatic.

A University of Iowa study of Chinese companies found that sometimes, employees just need a stable manager who can lead well with reliability. For teams that needed extra motivation or weren’t performing well, transformational leaders were helpful. However, for employees who were self-motivated, and teams that were already high-performing, the energy of transformational leaders was found to be disruptive.

“If (team) identification is high, transformational leadership efforts will meet with less success,” said study author Ning Li, professor of management and organizations. “Leaders need to tailor their transformational actions accordingly, rather than use a one-size-fits-all, group directed, transformational style.”

You might also like:
Providing vision: a key HR mandate
It’s just emotion, taking HR over
Leadership lessons from Nelson Mandela
 

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up-to-date with the world of HR. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from HRD America.

Recent articles & video

Why workers trust robots more than their managers

Davos 2020: Why are reskilling efforts failing?

Breastfeeding at work: How can HR help?

Fun Friday: Top 10 companies for remote workers

Most Read Articles

10 HR tech trends set to disrupt 2020

Fun Friday: Top 10 companies for remote workers

HRIS systems: What you need to know