The one way fear actually improves a workplace

Having problems with employees lashing out at particular supervisors? Don’t blame them…

The one way fear actually improves a workplace
Are employees lashing out against a supervisor they don’t like? It could well be because the supervisor doesn’t exert authority powerfully enough. That’s what researchers from the Canadian University of Waterloo found.

About three in four employees direct at least one aggressive act towards a supervisor every year, counting common signs of aggression like false gossip, mean-spirited pranks, and obscene gestures, studies show. But that type of retaliation is significantly more likely to occur when supervisors lack the means to punish subversive employees.

“Retaliating against an abusive boss sounds brave and intrepid even to the point of folly, but the more one analyzes it, the less courageous and foolish it turns out to be,” said researcher Huiwen Lian. “There's a great difference between retaliating against a powerful boss who can do you a lot of harm and a boss who cannot -- and cases of the latter are much more common than instances of the former.”

While self-control also plays a factor, noted the researchers, “the absence of self-control capacity or resources need not necessarily lead individuals to behave aggressively in response to abusive supervision. Given the proper incentives (i.e., perceiving potential punishment from supervisors), individuals appear to be quite capable of mobilizing their inner resources to override their natural inclination to directly harm an abusive supervisor.”

They also found that negative incentives, like the threat of punishment, were a better inhibitor of aggressive behavior than positive ones, like rewards.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up-to-date with the world of HR. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from HRD America.

Recent articles & video

HRD launches game-changing website redesign

What is the secret to a killer recruitment strategy?

How to foster a digital workplace culture

IWD: Is advocacy the answer to the gender gap?

Most Read Articles

HRD launches game-changing website redesign