A workplace complaint followed by a rapid c-suite redundancy raises plenty of questions
The sudden removal of Steadfast Group’s chief operating officer role—held until this week by Noelene Palmer—has intensified industry attention on how large organisations manage senior-level workplace complaints, as the ASX-listed broking group continues to deal with questions over governance and culture.
Palmer exited the business shortly after chief executive Robert Kelly returned to his duties following a confidential investigation into a workplace complaint. Multiple people familiar with the matter told the AFR that Palmer was the individual who lodged that complaint, which reportedly involved at least one inappropriate comment. Steadfast has repeatedly declined to confirm to the paper whether she was the complainant or to discuss the outcome of the review. Palmer has not commented.
Kelly stepped aside on full pay in October while the board commissioned an external investigation into the allegations.Steadfast later told the ASX the matter had “concluded on a confidential basis”, but provided no further detail about findings, remediation measures or recommendations—elements HR leaders would typically expect to be communicated internally when a senior figure is involved.
Read more: Steadfast confirms Robert Kelly to resume CEO duties
Only days after Kelly’s reinstatement, Palmer’s biography was removed from the Steadfast website. The company confirmed that the COO position had been eliminated entirely. A spokesperson said the change was part of expense management measures flagged at its October AGM, explaining that Steadfast had reviewed its operating model “to ensure the sustainable future of the organisation”, and that “the COO role was made redundant effective November 2025 and Steadfast will not be replacing the role.”
The sequence of events—complaint, investigation, reinstatement and near-immediate redundancy of the executive believed to have raised concerns—has unsettled parts of Steadfast’s network. Industry figures say the lack of transparency surrounding both the process and the implications for the organisation’s culture has fuelled unease. One broker told the Financial Review the situation “rattled people well beyond the company”.
For HR practitioners observing from across the sector, the episode highlights several contemporary challenges: managing complaints against high-profile CEOs, designing investigation processes with genuine independence, ensuring complainants are protected from adverse consequences, and communicating outcomes in a way that maintains internal trust while meeting legal constraints.
Palmer, who joined Steadfast in 2024 following senior roles at IAG, TAL, Swiss Re, KPMG and Westpac, was promoted to COO only five months ago. Earlier in the year, Kelly described her as bringing “a breadth of experience in insurance over her career” and said she was “a highly valued member of the Executive Leadership Team.” He also told staff and investors, “I reconfirm my commitment to not retire before 31 December 2026.”
Read next: Brokers respond to Steadfast CEO stepping down after "workplace complaint"
Her departure adds to a recent turnover of senior executives, including her predecessor as COO and the group’s longtime CFO. Steadfast is also subject to an ongoing ASIC investigation into potential insider trading involving two employees.
HR specialists note that organisations confronting multiple simultaneous governance challenges face heightened risks in areas such as psychological safety, whistleblower protections, leadership credibility and change fatigue. Where an executive believed to have made a protected disclosure leaves abruptly, experts say employers must take particular care to demonstrate that their processes were fair, consistent and free from reprisals.
The lack of clarity around Steadfast’s internal response—whether any cultural, behavioural or governance changes were recommended or adopted following the investigation—has left many in the broader industry watching closely. As one of the most influential players in the intermediated insurance market, Steadfast’s approach to complaints-handling and executive accountability is likely to inform how other organisations calibrate their own practices.
Steadfast has not provided further comment on Palmer’s departure or the details of the investigation.
