Professor sues Miami University over alleged caregiver double standard

Two decades without a bad review, then her father got sick

Professor sues Miami University over alleged caregiver double standard

A tenured professor is suing Miami University, alleging the school punished her for caregiving duties it praised in male colleagues.

The complaint, filed November 17, 2026, in the US District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, brings Title VII claims of sex discrimination and retaliation against the Oxford, Ohio public university, which enrolls nearly 22,500 students.

The professor holds a PhD from Ohio State University and alleges she built a strong career at Miami spanning more than two decades - without a single negative performance evaluation. She created the first web-based course in her department in 2001, won a Faculty Innovator Award from the State University System of Ohio in 2009, and co-developed the department's first fully online graduate program in 2013, according to the filing. She published two dozen peer-reviewed articles and created over 15 online courses.

Then her father got sick.

In May 2024, the professor became his primary caregiver, the complaint states. She did not take extended leave. She kept teaching - her courses were online, as they had been for over 20 years - and continued earning strong student evaluation scores while meeting her research and service requirements.

Her father's health deteriorated significantly in spring 2025, the filing alleges, with frequent hospitalizations. She missed several department meetings. She had previously told the acting department chair about her caregiving situation, the complaint states, but he "did not positively respond" and offered no support, professional or emotional.

In April 2025, the professor informed the chair she had admitted her father to hospice. Shortly after, she told him her father had died.

What came next, according to the complaint, was her first negative performance evaluation in more than 20 years.

The filing alleges the chair relied on the late submission of her 2024 annual report to justify a substantially lower performance rating - despite a department practice of using the prior year's report when submissions were late or missed. He withheld a salary increase the professor would have received under a newly established collective bargaining agreement, the complaint claims. He refused to amend the evaluation even after hearing the circumstances surrounding her father's illness and death.

The chair then initiated disciplinary action, the filing states, criticizing the professor for not being "collegial enough" and for missing meetings during spring 2025 - despite knowing her father had died just weeks earlier.

Here is where the complaint draws its sharpest contrast.

The filing identifies two male faculty members in the same department who also served as primary caregivers for seriously ill family members. One, during the 2018-2019 academic year, cared for his seriously ill wife while continuing to work. According to the complaint, he was "lauded" for keeping up his duties, was not disciplined for missing meetings, and received no lower performance ratings. The professor was even asked by the then-department chair to help him with his work during that period, the filing states.

The second male comparator is the acting department chair himself, the complaint alleges - who also provided caregiving for an ailing spouse. According to the filing, he was not subjected to extra scrutiny or criticism. He was praised. He was promoted to department chair.

The complaint also alleges the chair ramped up the professor's workload. During spring and summer 2025, he raised the fall enrollment cap on a long-standing online course from 35 students to 100, the filing states, while simultaneously cutting her graduate assistant support from the typical nine hours to a shared allocation of six hours among three professors. In October 2025, the complaint alleges, the chair directed her to convert an undergraduate course into an "AI Class" - with no release time or additional support.

In December 2025, the professor filed an EEOC charge about the gendered treatment she says she experienced.

After Miami received notice of the charge in February 2026, the complaint alleges conditions got worse. The chair - who was specifically named in the discrimination charge - assigned the professor to teach a course outside her area of expertise for fall 2026, the filing states, something the complaint calls "highly unusual" at Miami. The course was also to be taught in person. The professor had taught exclusively online for 22 years.

In March 2026, the complaint alleges, she received another low performance rating - this time "not meeting expectations" in the service category, without justification despite what the filing describes as strong objective measurements. A department colleague of the same rank with comparable performance was rated "met expectations," according to the complaint.

On March 10, 2026, the chair initiated disciplinary action against the professor for a second time, the filing states.

The complaint seeks back pay, compensatory damages in excess of $75,000, reinstatement with full benefits, prejudgment and post-judgment interest, and attorneys' fees.

For HR leaders, the case poses a pointed question: when caregiving responsibilities affect a worker's availability, is the organization's response consistent across genders - and can it prove it?

The allegations in the complaint have not been tested, and no court has made any findings or rulings on the merits.

LATEST NEWS