Benefitbay's Brandy Thompson on how ICHRA gives HR leaders a new tool to fix a broken benefits equation
For many HR directors, the annual benefits renewal has become a ritual of diminishing returns: costs climb, employee satisfaction stagnates, and the options on the table look largely the same as they did five years ago.
Brandy Thompson, co-founder and CEO of Benefitbay, thinks the individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement (ICHRA) – now also called a "CHOICE arrangement" – is the structural fix that HR leaders have been missing. The barrier, she says, is not the product. It is policy instability and a persistent education gap at the employer level.
"Employers are just having unsustainable outcomes regardless of the tool that they're pulling out of their tool chest," Thompson said. "There have been a lot of self-insurance cases that have inserted a lot of point solutions thinking they're going to be able to control cost, and they've been unsuccessful."
What ICHRA actually means for HR teams
Under a traditional group health plan, the employer selects a small number of options and bears the administrative and financial exposure when those plans underperform.
Under ICHRA, the employer sets a defined contribution, which can vary by geography, employment classification, or rating area, and employees use that allowance to purchase individual coverage on the market that fits their own health needs and family situation.
Rather than managing a one-size-fits-all plan across a workforce with divergent health needs, HR leaders can offer genuine choice while containing cost exposure. Rate increases become isolatable by geography rather than absorbed across the whole population.
"Just because a 13% increase happened in a certain market does not mean that's what the employer is going to experience," Thompson said. "In group insurance or self-insurance, you have one or two things that are getting out of balance – it causes it for the whole population. In ICHRA, it's isolated."
Benefitbay, which serves approximately 400 companies at an average of 1,000 employees each, has built its platform around the complexity that large employers actually face: Human Resources Information System (HRIS) integrations, Affordable Care Act (ACA) 1095 filing support, variable-compensation eligibility recalculation, and multi-rating-area contribution structures.
Those are the capabilities, Thompson argued, that smaller ICHRA platforms built on individual exchange rails cannot replicate and the capabilities that HR teams at mid-to-large organizations need before they can confidently make the switch.
The rebrand from "ICHRA" to "choice arrangement," introduced by the current administration, has added a layer of confusion that HR communicators will need to navigate.
Benefitbay uses both terms to avoid ambiguity, and Thompson acknowledged the timing was not ideal.
"We are really starting to get some education traction around the individual choice health reimbursement arrangement, and then we've gone to these other items that define what choice is," she said. "I did feel like the timing – it's not necessarily helpful for the market."
The employee experience problem ICHRA is designed to solve
For Thompson, the more urgent argument for ICHRA is not cost containment, it’s what the current system does to employees who cannot afford to use it.
"If we stay in HSA high-deductible health plans for a $40,000-a-year worker, they're not accessing care until they're at stage 4," she said. "We've got to get them in the plans they can afford that have zero deductible, zero copay – that maybe have a more narrow network, but they're going to actually access care."
The high-deductible health savings account (HSA) model, she noted, was designed around the salary-deferral needs of higher-earning employees. Applied across an entire workforce, it effectively prices lower-wage workers out of regular care access – a structural inequity that sits squarely within HR's remit on equitable benefits design. ICHRA removes that one-plan constraint, allowing individuals to select coverage calibrated to their actual financial situation and health needs, rather than to the tax planning preferences of the organization's highest earners.
Thompson also raised a data privacy dimension that HR leaders may not have fully considered. Under group insurance, an employee's health utilization data – prescriptions, diagnoses, claims history – flows back into the employer's underwriting profile. Under ICHRA, that link is severed.
"We do not need our drug data, our healthcare outcome data underwriting us for three years from now," she said. "That individual needs to be able to say, I'm on ABC drug, I'm going to have XYZ surgery, and I want to pick my healthcare based on those outcomes. My employer does not need to be in on that conversation."
Benefitbay offers access to its own licensed agents for employees who want to navigate sensitive health decisions, such as a cancer diagnosis or a planned surgery, without disclosing anything to their HR team or benefits broker.
What HR leaders should watch heading into 2027
Thompson identified administrative and legislative stability as the single biggest lever for accelerating employer adoption of ICHRA and expressed cautious optimism that 2027 will deliver it.
The past two open enrollment cycles were shadowed by significant uncertainty: a government shutdown during last year's enrollment window, ACA subsidy volatility, Medicaid cut fears, and carrier market exits. These created hesitation among employers who were otherwise ready to move.
"During open enrollment last year, the government was shut down. ACA was a very volatile. How are the subsidies going to affect their rates?" Thompson said. "Stability in the individual and the ACA market from an administrative policy level is what's going to drive adoption."
A narrative problem has compounded the policy uncertainty. Employers and employees routinely conflate on-exchange subsidy debates, which are politically charged and heavily covered, with off-exchange employer ICHRA access, which operates on a different track.
"The noise in the ACA tends to be political," Thompson said. "Sometimes it could be a bit of hyperbole, but in certain markets there is definitely an increase." HR communicators will need to address that conflation directly with their workforces during open enrollment.
Thompson was optimistic that the current legislative balance will produce a more stable environment. ICHRA originated under the first Trump administration and was expanded under the Biden administration – a genuinely bipartisan track record that she believes positions it well regardless of which direction Washington moves.
"I believe that we will continue to invest in healthcare and we will strengthen the ACA now, and that will cause the stabilization," she said.
One ground-level signal worth watching: dual-ICHRA households, where both spouses work for employers offering ICHRA, are now actively comparing their respective contributions and coverage outcomes at renewal.
"That was not something we were seeing a few years ago," Thompson said.
As ICHRA reaches critical mass, employee-driven demand for the product may begin to surface at the employer table, shifting the dynamic from HR-led rollout to workforce expectation.
For HR leaders looking to benchmark their current benefits strategy against the cost and coverage trends driving ICHRA interest, the Kaiser Family Foundation's annual employer health benefits survey provides peer data on premium growth, deductible levels, and employer cost-sharing trends. The Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration also publishes guidance on ICHRA compliance requirements for plan sponsors.
Thompson closed with the priority she returns to most: care navigation. Giving employees a choice of plan is only the beginning.
"We need to have care navigation really clear for that individual to make that choice, but then also to own their outcome throughout the year as they're accessing care," she said.
That means the communication and support infrastructure around ICHRA is as important as the product itself and the organizations that invest in it will see meaningfully better employee outcomes.