Only 4% of CHROs feel ready for AI. What's getting in the way?

Most organizations are still experimenting with AI. A new survey reveals what's holding them back and where CHROs should start

Only 4% of CHROs feel ready for AI. What's getting in the way?

Ask a CHRO how well their organization is handling AI and the answer usually comes with a qualifier. Most say they're at least somewhat prepared for the changes ahead, but hardly any would call themselves very prepared.

That picture comes from The Conference Board's latest CHRO Confidence survey, which also found the overall index slipping to 56 in the third quarter of 2026 from 58 in the second, a step down from the record high it reached earlier this year.

Diana Scott, U.S. Human Capital Center Leader at The Conference Board in New York, said she isn't surprised by how few CHROs feel very prepared.

"I don't know that it's a reflection of confidence," she said. "I think it's more of a reflection of where they are in the journey and that they feel like there's a lot of work ahead of them."

From experimenting to real transformation

While 55% of CHROs consider their organizations at least somewhat prepared to manage AI-driven workforce change over the next two years, only 4% say they're very prepared. The biggest barriers were difficulty predicting AI's workforce impact (41%), limited AI skills (39%) and an unclear AI strategy (31%). Just 19% say anticipated AI effects are built into workforce and financial planning across the enterprise.

"I think the 4% confidence is probably appropriate because our research shows that most organizations have not really embraced AI and have really not gotten very far in terms of their use of AI as much as we would think," Scott said. "They're experimenting, they're prototyping, they're beginning to pull it into their overall systems."

Getting further along means rethinking how work gets done, Scott said.

"You can't just think about it strictly from, 'Oh, I'm just going to bolt AI on my existing processes,' because that's not really where the real value is achieved," she said. "The real transformation happens when you actually look at an entire workflow and say, 'Okay, is AI going to augment? Is it going to automate? How is that work going to move to somebody else?'"

That analysis raises questions about new tasks and the skills employees will need, she said. It mirrors advice a Mercer executive gave HRD America earlier in 2026 about planning at the task and skill level rather than by job title.

Hiring holds while engagement slips

The survey also tracks how CHROs feel about hiring, retention and engagement, the three components of the confidence index. Any reading above 50 means more CHROs are positive than negative, so the overall mood is still positive at 56, though only one of those components improved.

Hiring rose from 59 to 61, while retention eased from 55 to 54 and engagement fell from 59 to 55. That engagement measure asks CHROs whether employees felt committed, motivated and connected over the past six months.

"I think if you break it down, it tells a more nuanced story," Scott said. "I think what it says is that overall they're feeling a little less confident about being able to retain their employees and, more importantly, to be able to engage their employees."

Fewer CHROs also expect overall workforce size to grow over the next six months, 49% compared with 55% in the second quarter.

Similarly, Gallup, which surveys workers directly and measures engagement differently, found that U.S. employee engagement fell to 29% in the third quarter of 2026, its lowest level since 2011.

Three practical first steps CHROs can take

Against that backdrop, the work of preparing for AI can feel overwhelming, and Scott said there are three steps CHROs can take to get started. The first is to start small.

That means picking one area of the company where a workflow doesn't seem very efficient, putting a team on it and testing whether technology can streamline the work across functions, she said. It's almost a prototype, with a couple of use cases, executive buy-in and resources behind them.

"You can't boil the ocean," Scott said. "You can't do it all at once. You have to begin to test. You've got to involve the employees in this because many of them understand how work happens and will have the ideas."

The second is building basic AI skills across the workforce, which speaks to the survey's second most cited barrier.

"How do I begin to design some programs just to involve my employees, get them skilled in basic AI?" Scott said. "And that's table stakes. If I haven't done that already, I need to make sure that that's in place."

Not every executive treats that as a priority, though. Businessolver research found that those focused on cutting headcount with AI are half as likely to prioritize AI upskilling as their peers.

The third step is communication. Gallup research has found that workers who use AI frequently are more than twice as likely to believe their jobs could disappear within five years, though manager support can substantially ease that worry.

"I think the narrative that is out there right now of, 'Oh, AI is going to take your job. AI is going to replace people.' And I think it's very important that the leadership be very clear about their overall vision of AI," Scott said.

Being open about what's still unknown matters too, she said.

"You can't promise them that there will be a job for them, but you can show them that there's a path," Scott said. "You can show them that there's growth. You can show them here's where you can go potentially, and that you're providing the tools and the support to guide them there."

LATEST NEWS