It’s at least the sixth such petition in under a year - and two Houston courts still disagree
Two construction firms tried to skip trial and jump straight to appeal over a workers’ compensation defense. A Texas court said no.
The First District Court of Appeals in Houston denied a mandamus petition from United Forming Inc. and Choice Contractors, LLC on November 13. The two companies were defendants in a workplace injury lawsuit in Harris County and had asked the trial court to throw out the claims against them under the Texas Workers’ Compensation Act’s exclusive-remedy provision - the rule that generally shields employers from being sued for on-the-job injuries when workers’ comp coverage is in place.
The trial court refused. So the contractors went over its head, filing a mandamus petition - essentially asking the appeals court to overrule the lower court without waiting for a full trial.
That did not fly either.
The central question was whether the exclusive-remedy defense works like an immunity from suit or a standard defense to liability. The difference is everything. A true immunity means the defendant should never have been in court at all. Once denied, that right is gone the moment a trial begins - which is why courts will sometimes step in early.
A defence to liability is different. The defendant still has to prove it, but the defence is not destroyed by going through trial. If a judge or jury gets it wrong, a regular appeal can fix it.
The court held the exclusive-remedy provision falls squarely into the second category. To drive the point home, it cited one of its own earlier cases where it overturned a $17 million jury verdict on the exclusive-remedy defence after a full trial. The process works - it just takes longer.
The ruling put the First District directly at odds with its neighbour. The Fourteenth Court of Appeals, also in Houston, reached the opposite conclusion in December 2025 in a case involving ExxonMobil, finding that denying an exclusive-remedy motion was extraordinary enough to justify immediate review.
The First District expressly disagreed.
It also flagged the flood of similar petitions. Since December 2025, it had received at least six mandamus filings on exclusive-remedy defences under Texas, Louisiana, and New Mexico law. Original-proceeding filings at the court have climbed more than 49% since 2024.
The underlying lawsuit remains pending in the 281st District Court of Harris County.
For HR and risk teams at Texas employers - especially in construction, energy, and other sectors with layered contractor arrangements - the takeaway is practical: losing a summary judgment motion on workers’ comp exclusivity will not trigger an immediate appeal. The defence survives, but it will need to be proved at trial and raised again on appeal if necessary.
Two Houston courts now disagree on the question. Whether the Texas Supreme Court steps in remains to be seen.