She was told mothers don’t get promotions. The hotel wanted that story told in private
A California appeals court has blocked a luxury hotel from forcing a former employee’s pregnancy harassment claim into private arbitration.
The Second Appellate District’s November 17 ruling turned on a question employers have been watching closely: does the federal Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act - known as the EFAA - cover gender and pregnancy harassment, or only claims involving sexual misconduct?
The court said it covers both.
The case involved a worker who spent nearly nine years as a guest reception manager at The Maybourne Beverly Hills before being terminated in January 2024. According to the complaint, as recounted by the court, things shifted after she disclosed her first pregnancy in October 2020. Comments were made that she would need to stop working and “would not be able to be a career woman once she had children.”
After returning from maternity leave, she applied for a director-level position but was never interviewed despite repeated follow-ups. The hotel closed the role and hired a man.
By December 2023, the pattern had hardened. When the worker asked about advancement, a regional director told her “she was a mother and that her first priority would always be her children,” then suggested she stop seeking promotions and look for other work. When she asked for fair compensation, she was told there was “no point in asking.”
Then came the false accusation. After the worker tried to escalate the matter to HR, the complaint alleged, the director of human resources accused her of having a sexual relationship with a coworker in hotel rooms - an allegation the complaint said was untrue. Despite an innocent explanation, the worker was placed on unpaid suspension and fired five days later.
She filed suit in March 2024 under California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act and elected to keep her claims in court under the EFAA.
Maybourne argued the EFAA only applied to claims involving lewd or lascivious conduct, pointing to the law’s #MeToo-era origins. The court rejected that reading. Because the EFAA directs courts to apply the definition of sexual harassment “under applicable Federal, Tribal, or State law,” the court looked to FEHA - which defines “sex” to include gender and pregnancy, and specifies that “sexually harassing conduct need not be motivated by sexual desire.”
Drawing on the US Supreme Court’s reasoning, the appeals court found that what Congress may have had in mind when it passed the EFAA did not limit the statute’s plain text.
For HR teams, the message is direct: arbitration clauses will not keep gender or pregnancy harassment claims out of court, even where no one alleges sexual advances. Employers relying on arbitration agreements as a catch-all for workplace harassment need to revisit that assumption.
The decision is certified for publication and binding on California trial courts. The underlying claims have not been tried on the merits.