Kaiser Permanente unit loses free-speech bid to sink discrimination lawsuit

The physician alleged bias, retaliation, and a constructive discharge after 15 years

Kaiser Permanente unit loses free-speech bid to sink discrimination lawsuit

Kaiser Permanente’s medical group has failed in its attempt to use a free-speech law to shut down a physician’s discrimination and retaliation lawsuit early. 

A California appeals court ruled on November 13 that The Permanente Medical Group (TPMG) could not wield the state’s anti-SLAPP statute - a law designed to quickly dismiss meritless lawsuits targeting free speech - to knock out the physician’s entire complaint. The core employment decisions at the heart of his claims, the court held, were not the kind of protected activity the statute covers. 

The physician had worked for TPMG for about 15 years. He alleged the company discriminated against him based on his sexual orientation and retaliated after he flagged misconduct by a colleague. According to the complaint, he was told to drop the matter. 

In October 2021, TPMG placed him on paid leave and barred him from patient care, citing allegations of illegal drug use. By early 2022, it had preliminarily concluded the drug use impaired his work. A recommendation to terminate followed in May 2022. The physician was told to resign within a week or face suspension without pay. He refused. 

Then came a tangle of exit doors. In December 2022, the physician sent a letter asserting he had been constructively discharged - effectively forced out. TPMG treated the letter as a resignation and separately fired him for allegedly violating its sick leave policy. 

A consolidated peer review hearing finally started in March 2023. When TPMG asked the physician about drug use, he declined to answer. The panel deemed him to have voluntarily accepted both the patient-care restriction and the termination recommendation. TPMG’s board affirmed those outcomes in May 2023. 

The physician sued on seven grounds, including whistleblower retaliation, discrimination under the Unruh Civil Rights Act, wrongful constructive discharge, and unfair competition. 

TPMG’s defense was procedural. It filed an anti-SLAPP motion arguing every claim arose from its peer review process - activity that can qualify as protected speech under California law. The employer wanted the entire complaint thrown out before discovery. 

The trial court drew a line. It struck the allegations tied directly to peer review but refused to touch claims resting on actual employment decisions - the suspension, the termination recommendation, and the firings. 

The appeals court agreed. Claims based entirely on unprotected conduct - the employer’s disciplinary and termination decisions - sit outside the anti-SLAPP statute’s reach. If TPMG believes those claims are legally defective, the proper tool is a formal challenge to the pleadings, not an anti-SLAPP motion. 

The court also rejected TPMG’s challenge to allegations about pre-hearing disciplinary actions and a peer review panelist removed for lying under oath, finding those served as evidence of motive rather than standalone claims. 

For HR teams, the message is practical: internal proceedings like peer review do not shield the employment decisions sitting alongside them. Suspensions, terminations, and disciplinary calls remain open to legal challenge regardless of the process wrapped around them. 

The decision is final. The physician is entitled to recover costs on appeal. 

LATEST NEWS