Interior Department defeats telework accommodation claim by keeping the conversation going

A new supervisor approved the same telework request just months later

Interior Department defeats telework accommodation claim by keeping the conversation going

A federal employee’s bid to sue over a denied telework request has collapsed after a court found his employer never stopped trying to accommodate him. 

The US District Court for the District of Columbia granted summary judgment to the Department of the Interior on November 18, dismissing both a failure-to-accommodate claim under the Rehabilitation Act and a retaliation claim under Title VII. 

The employee, a grants management specialist in the department’s Fish and Wildlife Service, had asked to work from home two days a week. He said he suffered from work-related syncope - a condition causing fainting episodes - along with outbreaks of hives. 

In August 2013, his supervisor told him the medical records he had submitted were not sufficient and asked his doctor for updated documentation. The employee indicated his doctor would not be providing anything beyond what had already been sent. His supervisor then offered alternatives: a different workstation and flexibility around medical appointments, telling the employee the accommodation process was ongoing. 

He rejected the alternatives. His supervisor followed up in writing, explaining that the telework request had been denied because he was still learning a new electronic reporting system and his job responsibilities. But she also wrote that reasonable accommodation was “an iterative process that we should return to discuss periodically,” and scheduled a follow-up meeting for October 2013. 

Then his supervisor changed. In December 2013, the new supervisor granted the two-day telework arrangement. 

The employee argued the original denial proved the department failed him. The court disagreed. Under the Rehabilitation Act, an employer does not fail to accommodate simply by declining a preferred arrangement - it only fails when it ends the back-and-forth process entirely or acts in bad faith. Here, the department stayed engaged throughout. 

The court also found the roughly four-month gap between the initial request and eventual approval was not unreasonable, citing precedent holding that even seven-month delays can fall within acceptable bounds. 

His second claim fared no better. He alleged his supervisor questioned him about an equal employment opportunity complaint during a performance appraisal meeting, amounting to retaliation. The court acknowledged the questioning was “inappropriate” but found no evidence it actually discouraged him from pursuing his complaint. One question in one meeting, without more, did not clear the bar. 

For HR teams fielding accommodation requests, the takeaway is straightforward: the interactive process protects employers who stay in it. Offering alternatives, asking for documentation, and keeping the lines open can turn what looks like a denial into a defensible sequence. 

The ruling resolved all remaining claims. The employee, who represented himself, also had motions for terminating sanctions and to correct the administrative record denied. 

LATEST NEWS