The container door opened 30 miles in - four riders hit the sludge at highway speed
A waste company’s truck spilled sewage across a Kentucky interstate - and what happened next cost it $11 million.
The Kentucky Court of Appeals upheld the verdict on November 13, 2026, rejecting every argument Freedom Waste Services raised on appeal.
On May 31, 2022, a Freedom Waste driver was hauling a container of human waste along Interstate 24 when the door came open 30 miles into the trip. Waste poured across both lanes. The driver pulled over, called his manager, and tried to strap the door shut.
Four motorcyclists riding behind him at 60 to 70 miles per hour hit the sludge without warning. It caked into their tyres, they lost traction, and one by one they crashed - sliding through the waste on the pavement.
All four wore protective gear and were experienced riders. It did not help. Injuries ranged from a broken clavicle to road rash contaminated with sewage. Several needed wound cleaning procedures and were still picking waste particles from their injuries weeks later. Some required surgery or physical therapy. All reported emotional distress, including the trauma of seeing a fellow rider lying motionless on the road.
They sued in April 2023, alleging Freedom Waste violated Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations requiring loads to be properly secured.
Freedom Waste did not dispute those duties at trial. It acknowledged the load should not have spilled. Its entire defence rested on the driver’s claim that he had properly latched and secured the container before departing.
That claim fell apart under cross-examination.
No pin or safety chain was found at the scene. No evidence showed either had ever been attached to the container. And Freedom Waste had repaired the container’s latching mechanisms the day after the incident - leaving the driver’s word as the only evidence the container was secure when it left.
The driver’s credibility took a further hit. He claimed “absolute certain recall” of the container that day, yet could not remember other loads from the same shift. During an earlier deposition, he had circled a part on a photograph and identified it as something on the container before the spill. That part was actually added the day after. When confronted at trial, he denied remembering the deposition - until the video was played showing him doing exactly that.
On May 29, 2025, a unanimous jury found the company and driver had breached their duties. It awarded the four riders $11 million in pain and suffering, on top of medical costs ranging from $2,307.60 to $61,128.68 each.
Freedom Waste appealed on five grounds - challenging the admission of the post-repair photograph, opposing counsel’s trial comments, testimony about the company’s failure to conduct post-accident drug testing, its lack of any meaningful post-incident investigation, and the size of the damages award. The appeals court rejected every argument, noting the company had failed to object to most of the evidence at trial and had itself submitted jury instructions containing the same damages caps the jury awarded in full.
For HR teams overseeing drivers or field workers, the case shows how gaps in post-incident protocols - testing, investigation, equipment documentation - can become a company’s biggest liability at trial.
The decision is a published opinion of the Kentucky Court of Appeals. It may be subject to further appeal.