Six weeks on the job, a 100-page packet, and an arbitration clause with no expiry date
A California court has struck down an employment arbitration agreement that would have bound a call center worker to arbitration for life.
The Court of Appeal for California’s Second Appellate District ruled on November 13, 2026, that VXI Global Solutions - a company running call centers across the US - could not enforce the arbitration clause it gave a former account associate when she started in February 2023. She lasted about six weeks.
When VXI Global Solutions hired the worker, it handed her a roughly 100-page new hire packet. Included in the middle were an arbitration agreement and a confidentiality agreement. The worker, who had a high school education and no familiarity with arbitration, signed both without consulting a lawyer.
The arbitration agreement was written by the company but phrased as if the worker were speaking. It required her to arbitrate “all individual claims or controversies” - “whether or not” they arose from her employment. The company’s definition of itself stretched to include all past and present partners, officers, directors, employees, subsidiaries, affiliates, and their successors.
The clause never expired. It survived her departure and could only be revoked if she and all of the company’s partners agreed in writing. That meant the worker had effectively signed away her right to go to court against VXI Global Solutions or any of its affiliates, on virtually any issue, for the rest of her life. And the obligation only ran one way.
The trial court refused to enforce it. The appellate court, splitting 2-1, agreed.
The majority found low procedural unconscionability - it was a standard take-it-or-leave-it form - but the substance was another story. The agreement’s overbroad scope, indefinite duration, and lopsided application all weighed against VXI Global Solutions.
The confidentiality agreement made things worse. It gave the company the right to seek a court injunction without proving irreparable harm, and it barred the worker from recruiting any company employees for a year after leaving - a nonsolicitation clause the court found void under California law.
Reading both agreements together, the court counted at least five unconscionable provisions - meaning terms so one-sided they shock the conscience. That was too many to fix by cutting a clause. Rewriting the agreement to limit it to employment disputes would have meant adding terms the parties never agreed to, and courts cannot do that.
The dissent cut the other way. Justice Wiley argued the majority was applying a uniquely harsh standard found only in arbitration cases. He surveyed 713 California unconscionability decisions from 2021 to 2025 and found that between 79% and 90% targeted arbitration - a pattern he called “antipathy to arbitration.”
For HR teams, the decision reads like a drafting checklist in reverse: scope creep beyond employment, no expiry date, definitions that sweep in affiliates without matching obligations, and companion confidentiality clauses with unenforceable restrictions.
The worker’s underlying class action - alleging unpaid minimum wages, overtime, and missed meal and rest breaks - remains pending.