Cash not an incentive to stay

20/10/2011 | 1 comments
As we enter the festive season of holiday bonuses, two workplace experts have advised employers that money won't buy loyalty or happiness from an employee.
Speaking to The Sydney Morning Herald, Anthony Grant, director of the coaching psychology unit at the University of Sydney, said that while financial security was obviously necessary, handing out cash bonuses would not encourage employees to work harder or faster, and would certainly not be a deciding factor in staying or going.
Dr Grant said money is something that doesn’t increase positive satisfaction, but not having it is what leads to dissatisfaction.
“Once a household has an income of $100,000 a year, money is not a key motivator,” Dr Grant said.
In terms of keeping an employee happy, employers need to do more about ensuring an employee has proper resources, respect, and that their mental health is considered.
“If they don't have the resources to do their job well, not just adequately, this will not just demotivate people, it will really p*ss them off,” Dr Grant said.
He added that what works in the long term is having a strong team culture, recognition and respect, and most importantly, not having employees feel like they are part of a machine, or ‘just a number’.
Dr Keri Spooner, head of postgraduate HR management at the Sydney’s University of Technology, said making an employee feel recognised can be as easy as “providing lunch at a meeting”.
Dr Spooner warned that the biggest mistake employers made when handing out incentives was that they did not consider what behaviour it encouraged.
“[Incentives] have to be very carefully aligned with what you are trying to achieve,” Dr Spooner said.
One example of this, she said, would be a person who is paid a bonus for selling more of a product but may then be inclined to spend less time finding out what product was best for a customer.
Dr Spooner also dismissed the notion that cash incentives would encourage people to work harder.

“Money does not buy loyalty and it doesn't buy commitment. It is such a common commodity that if that is all that is keeping you in a job - all someone has to do is offer you more and you're gone," she said.

 

Latest News

Woman sues after alleged HR failings
Competency of next gen leaders questioned

Executives stripping away at HR function


Most Discussed

Bookmark and Share ALB

Latest Comments

Total: 1 comment(s)

Tamara Duffy on 23 Oct 2011 06:12 PM

Agreed, and this why counter offers rarely work when employees try to resign. According to statistics, ninety-eight percent of the time, the employee leaves within six months.


E-Newsletter

enews
Daily breaking news, video interviews, opinion and analysis delivered straight to your inbox.
Subscribe Today
HC Magazine issue 10.4

E-Mag

HC Magazine issue 10.4 OUT NOW
Thinking global, acting local – HR and globalisation; What’s your China strategy ...

view online

E-Mag Get Updated

HC Magazine issue 10.4
HC magazine's e-mag provides all of the in-depth news, opinion and analysis available in our print edition straight to your inbox
Subscribe Today

Your comment

Human capital forum is the place for positive industry interaction and welcomes your professional and informed opinion.
Name

Comment



By submitting, I agree to Terms & Conditions